13/04/2024
Many people want to instinctively stop a dog from growling. While a growling dog is not a happy encounter, it is still much better to get a warning growl from the dog rather than to encounter a dog who gives no warning before defaulting to a physical bite.
So don't punish the dog for growling. Address the underlying problem for the growl but do not remove the early warning system that might keep someone from getting bitten.
The Important Communication Of A Dog Growl
By Margit Maxwell
There are multitude of reasons why a dog might issue a growl.
Fear,
Overwhelm,
Stress,
Advanced Age, illness or chronic pain,
Anxiety,
Annoyance,
Anger,
a Lack of Obedience Training and Rule Setting,
or a Breed of Dog Who Is Vocal and Prone to Display Alerting Behaviors.
But the most likely and important reason for a dog to emit a growl is an EARLY WARNING showing that unless the current situation changes, a bite is likely to follow.
A Growl Is Like The Smoke Detector In Your Home
Smoke detectors are installed in homes to give early warning to the homeowner that a full blown house fire is imminent. These devices give a signal to the people at the very first early smoke stages of a fire so that they can act before the flames fully engulf the house making it too late for them to take appropriate action.
When a dog responds to a situation with a growl, this growl is the early warning system alerting the by standers that the dog is uncomfortable with what is going on in his immediate environment.
Encouraging your dog not to emit that warning growl is the equivalent of removing the batteries from the smoke detector in your home. You have now removed the only warning signal that alerts you to the impending imminent danger. The early warning of a potential biting situation allows you the opportunity to take evasive action thereby preventing the dog bite from happening.
Well respected Behaviourist Dr. Ian Dunbar refers to punishing the growl as "removing the ticker from the time bomb".
Don’t Punish The Growl, Understand The Reason For The Growl
Many dog owners find themselves embarrassed by their dog’s display of seemingly anti-social growling behaviour. But rather than being embarrassed, owners should seek to embrace this behaviour display as an opportunity to realize that their dog has a bigger unaddressed behaviour issue boiling beneath the surface. However, allowing the growl may help to avert a dog bite situation but it does nothing to fix the underlying problem behaviour that is causing the dog to feel uncomfortable in the first place.
The number one reason for a dogs to growl is to alert to the fact that the dog is feeling FEARFUL. When dogs do not know how to handle the stress of a situation or circumstance, the normal thing for them to do is default to being afraid. When dogs cannot predict how a situation might unfold or they fear how a situation might unfold, they default to a physiological Fight or Flight response. The growl serves first to offensively drive away the fear inducing subject and also defensively to warn the subject that if they don’t retreat, there will be a defensive act (the bite) to follow.
Other Common Root Causes For The Growl And What You Can Do To Help
Lack of Early Socialization Causing Fear or Anxiety
The purpose of early socialization is to desensitize dogs to new experiences. When a dog is missing socialization or has been insufficiently socialized to a wide enough variety of stimuli, dogs are very likely to respond to the unfamiliar stimuli (people, dogs, unfamiliar surrounds, smells, or sounds) with fear. If your dog is growling in response to fear caused by a lack of socialization, then the remedy for this problem is for the dog to be gently and gradually be exposed to new and unfamiliar stimuli without overwhelm and flooding. Using desensitization and counter conditioning to the trigger techniques, while making sure that your dog remains under the Threshold of Reactivity, can help to change your dog’s experience of the frightening experience and make it more pleasant and less scary for them.
People Or Dog Aggression
If your dog growls because he is uncomfortable with the presence or proximity of new people or other dogs, he is showing you that he does not possess the skills to be able to handle the stress of this encounter. Dogs can also be demonstrating that they have no idea how the encounter might unfold so they fear getting hurt or attacked. This situation can be averted by watching for the early communications from your dog that they are fearful (stiff body, staring at the target, flagging tail, hackles raised etc.) and not bringing your dog in so close the trigger object. By remaining further back, you help your dog stay Under the Threshold of Reactivity where you can then work on desensitization and counter conditioning to the fear inducing object.
Annoyances Coming From the Environment
Not all dogs have the same capacity for tolerance and not all dogs have the same likes or preferences. If your dog is signaling that they are uncomfortable with any kind of interaction, from human or another dog, then stop the interaction or remove your dog from the environment. Sadly, most humans, especially non dog owners, are not very well versed about accurately interpreting the signals being given by dogs that their intrusion into their personal space is not only unappreciated, it is unwanted.
If you know that your dog has a low threshold for tolerance, then be proactive and remove yourself and your dog to a more remote area. If you are in a waiting room, pick a seat well away from the entrance or the front desk to cut down on close proximity encounters. If the waiting room happens to be quite full of patients or clients that day, alert the receptionist that you wish to check in but that you will be waiting outside with your dog. The staff can either physically come to get you or they can call you on your cell phone to let you know that you that it’s time for your appointment.
Advanced Age, Illness or Chronic Pain
When dogs endure chronic pain, it can leave them cranky or short tempered. Be proactive by not taking your dog into situations where people or other dogs might physically touch or interact with your dog. Opt for individual leashed walks instead of going to the dog park. If you have guest in your home, consider placing the dog behind a safety gate, in another room, or placing him in the confines of his crate to help keep him and others safe.
If you have a senior dog who is showing signs of Canine Cognitive Dysfunction Disorder (doggy dementia) then just like in humans with dementia who find themselves not recognizing things in their environment, your dog will show signs of fear even in very common situations. You will have no warning when they might become confused or aggressive and there might not even be a warning growl issued before a bite is deployed. You will have to be very proactive with these senior dogs and the best thing to do is to limit the interactions and over stimulation in their environment. These dogs will do better with calm, quiet and predictable environments.
Growling Due To A Lack of Obedience Training Or Enforced Rules
We invite dogs to live in our world but our human world is filled with human societal rules that seem not only unnatural to dogs, they don’t make a lot of sense to them either. However, with the introduction of Obedience Training (the explanation of the rules of our human society and our expectations for their response and behaviour) we can help give our dogs the understanding of the behaviours that we would like to see from them in any given social situation. But if you don’t train to give dogs the rules about their behaviour or if you don’t enforce these rules, then dogs pretty much assign their own rules for their behaviour. The problem will be that the dog’s way to handle the situation may not fit well into the rules of our human society.
If your dog aggressively growls and lunges at people or other dogs, ask yourself, have you effectively shown your dog your rules for how to behave in this situation or are just expecting your dog give the appropriate behaviour because he “should already know how to behave”? Unless you put in the time to train your dog to give you the desired behaviours, you should not be surprised why your dog is responding to new, frightening, or overwhelming behaviours by growling and being afraid.
Don’t Punish The Growl But Also Don’t Ignore The Problem Behind The Growl
DON’T correct the growl itself as it could help prevent the opportunity for a dog bite to occur but DO identify and address the issue of why the dog is showing fear, stress, anxiety, or aggression in response to a situation. Ignoring the root cause of the problem means that you will be forever relegated to only managing the fallout of your dog’s behaviour instead of actually extinguishing the problem behaviours.