08/06/2023
We don't get to decide what's aversive and what's reinforcing to our dog, our dog is the only one who does.
My dog will search relentlessly to find a Kong hidden in the grass but can take or leave food when outdoors. He finds food reinforcing when doing training inside. There are a number of reasons for both these things.
He hates going out in the rain, other dogs don't mind at all.
My dog, Kitty, from years ago, looked as if her world ended if you said a harsh word to her (she was a Neapolitan Mastiff). This was before I trained positively. She didn't mind the rain.
Some dogs will work for kibble, others need a more tasty paycheck.
All dogs find pain aversive to some degree or another, that's why we evolved to feel pain. It's there to escape or avoid.
We have to understand the effect of these things on our dogs' behaviour. We need to have a proper understanding of the science of behaviour change.
Someone commented yesterday that you could use prong collars as positive reinforcement. You can't. You just can't. The same person said that pressure/release is positive reinforcement. It's not, it's negative reinforcement.
Until we have a proper understanding of the rules of behaviour and the emotions which go with it, our dogs will keep paying the price for our ignorance.
We all need to do better. Seriously.
Love and peace.