23/05/2024
Bit of a controversial post today š
This video shared by Dundee Dog Training has riled people up no end; people complaining about showing another trainers technique, people saying this training is fine, people saying the whole video should be shown blah blah blah
Iām here to say that if your trainer (or anyone you know) trains their dog with this aversive yank method, they are causing your/their dog distress for absolutely no need. I may be a new trainer in the sense that Iāve only started training other peoples dogs this year BUT Iād like to add my piece from experience.
I used to believe in heavily correctional and aversive training methods with little to no positive reinforcement in order to tell the dog what I donāt want it to do. Surely if you tell it what you donāt want itāll stopā¦ right and do what you want instead? Because itās logicalā¦ right? We tell our kids off when we donāt want them to do something, the dog should understand in the same wayā¦
In fact it couldnāt be further from the truth. All using these types of aversive methods (in this case id class this as abusive) will do is destroy your relationship with your dog and leave them feeling confused with what you actually want. If your dog is reactive, yanking them around will make them worse, and eventually youāll destroy the relationship so much that your dog will think youāre awful to be around and wonāt want anything to do with youā¦ remember that guy you saw on the park whoās dog never came back to him and when he did he hit it? Yeah you may as well be doing that.
Yes in this video itās the trainer and not the owner (I think) but Iād not let anyone treat my animals in this way because thereās just no need. This method can harm your dogs joints and in fact could even make your dog fear reactive to the point of biting other humans.
Loose leash walking and reactivity can be achieved without causing your dog distress (wow can you believe it!) or making your dog think youāre an ass.
And I would know this because this is how I used to train my own dogs and yes I damaged our relationship so much that they just didnāt know what to expect from me and didnāt know what they actually needed to do. If your dog is sensitive or nervous as well, youāre going to make them worse by doing things like this. Now I train 99% force free (never using abusive methods like in the video) and my dogs are happier, we have the best bond and weāve begun our journey in competitive dog sports.
So why force free might look boring or that youāre just giving the dog treats, there is a reason and that is because it works and it will make your dog want to be around you and look to you when they feel unsure. Dogs are not humans and they dont understand punishment in the same way as we think of it, but all living creatures like food and basic operant conditioning will tell us that we can train responses in a nice manner without causing stress and everyone feels happier and no one gets upset, abused or injured.