21/06/2022
Spot on!
Humans LOVE asking dogs to sit! It's often the first thing we teach them and it's super helpful ; before crossing a road, waiting for food to be put on the floor, going through doorways, on narrow pathways when someone approaches, when we stop and chat, when there's something too exciting... 👍
But here's the thing. It's not necessarily a natural behaviour for dogs. I read recently that wild canids and street dogs rarely sit for long, usually only in transition between lying down and standing, or changing their resting position, or to stretch or scratch or groom themselves.*
Sitting puts pressure on lots of joints and can't be very comfortable for many breeds of domestic dog, because of their highly accentuated body shapes. Excessive sitting can cause problems for growing puppies and sitting might be very painful for elderly dogs. Sadly, if a sit is a default position, one they are asked to do a lot throughout their lives (and so do without even thinking), elderly dogs will continue to sit, even though it causes them pain. And we might not even realise, because dogs are very good at hiding their pain. 😢
And in certain situations, it's entirely UNnatural. Sitting is super hard for wiggly bottoms, for example! 😉
A sit when a dog feels in any way vulnerable might be almost impossible. In a vulnerable situation (perhaps a really busy place, or a new place, or an unknown dog approaching head on with a strange vibe), most dogs would prefer to be on all four feet. 🐕🐩
When any strange dog is approaching, most dogs will likely choose standing, to be able to appropriately greet (sniff butts), join in play, or escape easily, if necessary. Depending on the specific circumstances (very big dog with small dog approaching), some dogs might choose a down position, either to make friends more easily, or possibly because they prefer to keep their bellies to the ground in self protection. 👌
I guess some dogs might choose to sit rather than lie down (certainly in a sphinx-like position) on concrete or tiles. It can't be comfy for canine elbows and neither surface is exactly natural. But I doubt any dog would choose, for themselves, to sit on a wet and dirty kerb, rather than simply to *stand* and wait to cross the road. 🤷♀️
Many of the people I really admire are publicly questioning our *motives* for training our dogs (I'll pop some links in the comments). That's not to say they think that we shouldn't train dogs at all. Rather, that we should always start by asking ourselves, "WHY?" 🤔
🐶 When changing a behaviour, WHY is our dog doing that? What need does it fulfil? How can we help them fulfil that need?
🐶 When teaching a new behaviour, WHY am I teaching her this? What benefit is it to HER?
WHY do I need Pepper to sit? 🐶
I've thought long and hard, but I honestly can't think of a single situation where a sit couldn't be replaced by a stand, or lie down. I think most humans like a sit when they want their dog to do nothing, to just wait, to be still for a moment or two. Or to stay. Or to settle, to simply hang out for a while longer. 👍
Even then, I question myself. Sometimes I really need Pepper to settle, at a cafe, or in a business meeting, or on the train, or when I'm cooking, or when the kids are here. Generally, she's pretty chilled out in all those situations. But does she actually have to do nothing? Would she prefer to be chewing, or sniffing, or problem-solving? Sometimes. And I can't think of a situation where I couldn't make that possible for her. 👌
Sitting is so overrated, people! And that's coming from someone who was once a bit of a sit ju**ie. 😉
* I can't remember where I read about wild and street dogs sitting! 🤦♀️ I think it might have been in a group conversation with someone who has studied street dogs personally. I can't find an published study, but it would be very interesting. Or a study into our domesticated dogs. 🐶
You could do some research with your own dogs! How often (and for how long) do they choose to sit in various situations, those that they haven't been specifically trained for? Maybe you could compare the sits you know you've trained, with those you think you haven't. And how many times does your new, untrained, puppy choose to sit? How often does your dog seem reluctant to sit? I'd love to know! 🐾💜