02/08/2024
WHO ARE THE ESVCN?!
Just chatting over on the membership, in regards to nutritional guidelines for dogs, someone asked what the difference was between AAFCO and FEDIAF. And are WSAVA (World Small Animal Veterinary Association), are they any better? And what about the ESVCN (The European Society of Veterinary & Comparative Nutrition) that some social media vets bandy around?!
First, I have a cool (if I do say so myself) course on AAFCO up on drconorbrady.com. It details why their guidelines are nonsense and virtually unusable. I go through the science used to support their stance that the MINIMUM amount of (crap quality) protein for a dog or cat is the BEST way to feed those animals FOR LIFE. I also go through what they say about carbs and then it's a roller coaster ride of horror through the science supporting their (factory-sourced) vitamin and mineral figures.
It really has be seen to be believed. It's actually quite relieving, seeing the little Oz peddling the machine, because once you KNOW they haven't a clue, it takes the pressure off you having to know what the ideal, perfectly complete diet is for a dog (when you have no idea for the kids!!).
So do check that course out (it's €29.95, free to Den members).
Anyway, it details that FEDIAF, the European Pet Food Federation, is simply the EU version of AAFCO. Two cheeks of the same arse. They run no trials, make no checks, have no extra sciecne at their disposal whatsoever. Their guidelines are based almost entirely on AAFCOs made up numbers with a few minor tweaks that don't really matter a damn, in the grand scheme of things.
WSAVA and the same.
I have to admit, I was initially surprised to hear the name ESVCN being thrown around as I haven't heard of a single study or data point produced by them. What are they contributing to the debate? Well, nothing....bar influence.
You see, much like the word "foundation" (eg the Bill & Melinda Foundation, which is the tax-free influencing front of their vaccines business), as soon as you see a group boast that they are NON PROFIT you should immediately set about finding out who's paying for the pizza you are about to eat.
In this case, the European Society of Veterinary & Comparative Nutrition tells us it is proudly sponsored by BIG DRY FOOD. It's raison d'etre is to promote BIG DRY FOOD.
Their mission statement is as follows (caps added by me for effect):
"...to generate interest, STIMULATE research and disseminate knowledge in veterinary nutrition, comparative nutrition and nutrition-related diseases; to PROMOTE pre- and post-graduate education in veterinary and comparative nutrition; to STIMULATE the application of clinical nutrition in veterinary schools by cooperation between nutritionists and clinicians; and to COOPERATE with other societies with related interests."
To stimulate this and promote that. In other words, to direct cash where appropriate to get the actions / studies / responses they require to keep the show on the road.
And to cooperate with "other societies".....right, except the Raw Feeding Veterinary Society, of course, still the only group of vets IN THE WORLD campaigning for real food for pets.
It's rotten, isn't it?!
If a vet quotes them as a source, just let them know that you don't take your nutritional licks from Ronald McDonald. They won't like that.