10/07/2025
Because colonialism is so centred around ownership, control, exploitation, and having dominion over others, the idea of giving a dog more agency can only sound like “Your dog should dominate you, walk all over you, and be completely out of control” to those with colonial mindsets (and that includes a lot of binary thinking).
But we know dogs are not hierarchical beings, we know dogs are more collaborative than we give them credit for, we know dogs are not here to serve us, and we know we can be in community with our dogs.
So we also know that dogs having more agency in their lives as just a right they deserve to have as sentient beings on this earth.
Yes, we live in a human-centric world and some of our dogs’ choices may be limited at times for their safety, but because we recognise this reality, we can actively choose to give our dogs more agency whenever it is safe. And the way we can think about it can be like the way we think about how we are with people we’re in community with, because we all need help to be safe and feel safe from time to time too.
A dog being able to communicate their needs and wants, express how they feel, move comfortably and freely, engage in natural behaviours, and tell us “no” or that they need a moment, is not the downfall of humanity or leading to dogs taking over the world. Dogs don’t have colonial mindsets.
If anything, a dog who has more agency and knows their needs will be heard is more likely to engage with us and learn with us because they feel safe in their relationship with us.
Agency is a basic need, a basic right, and an important part of a sentient animal’s wellbeing.
Enjoy being in community with your dog, enjoy your dog having fun doing what they enjoy, and enjoy your “ungovernable” dog like I do mine.
ID: The background photo is of Dave, a brown Singapore Special dog with pointy ears, standing off leash on the beach and looking out to the other side of the beach across the stream. The text here says “Colonial mindsets are based on ownership, exploitation, and binary thinking. That’s why when people hear ‘Dogs deserve more agency’, they can only imagine ‘Your dog is going to dominate you and run wild’”.