17/05/2025
'IVE TRIED AN ELECTRIC COLLAR MYSELF AND IT DOESN'T HURT'
I've often been asked why I don't use electric collars in my training methods.
1. Using them goes against my morals and ethics as a person.
2. It goes against the codes of conduct of the professional bodies I belong to and support (IMDT, KAD, ICB, PACT).
Sadly I'm getting more clients coming to me where they've been working with 'professionals' in the past that use these methods. Rather than criticise the previous 'professional' and make my client feel worse (let's be honest they thought they were doing the right thing by trying to get help), my response is the past has happened. I explain all the good things about using kind methods and we move forward together positively!
3. Not only am I a skilled, experienced and accredited professional, my work is evidence based and supported by SCIENCE. This brilliant post below by Roman explains the science behind what really happens when you use an electric collar on your dog.....
âĄď¸THE $6,000 VOLT LIE: What Theyâre Not Telling You About âLow-Levelâ Shock Training
đ¨This Applies Also To Vibration Collars
âItâs just a mild stim, like a TENS unit. Totally safe.â
No itâs Not!!!
Letâs walk through exactly what happens inside your dogâs neck when you hit that remote. Not just emotionallyâbut biologically.
Because once you understand whatâs happening under their skin, youâll see this isnât a communication toolâitâs a nervous system atomic bomb.
Youâre Not Hitting One NerveâYouâre Hitting a Highway of Sensory Chaos
When you shock a dogâs neck, youâre not delivering a clean signal to a single behavior center. Youâre triggering a web of critical nerves, including:
Vagus Nerve (Cranial X)
⢠Regulates heart rate, digestion, and emotional calm
⢠Overstimulation can cause nausea, bradycardia, or collapse
Accessory Nerve (Cranial XI)
⢠Controls head movement and postural muscles
⢠Disruption causes jerking, reactivity, or defensive freezing
Cervical Spinal Nerves (C1âC5)
⢠Link to forelimbs and breathing muscles
⢠Disturbance can create stumbling, stiffness, or panic movement
Phrenic Nerve (C3âC5)
⢠Controls breathing via the diaphragm
⢠Overload causes panting, respiratory distress, or emotional shutdown
Auricular & Transverse Cervical Nerves
⢠Involved in ear, jaw, and neck sensation
⢠Trigger head shaking, pawing, scratching, or vocalization
And all of these are stimulated at once when you push that button.
Now Add This: The Skin Itself Is a Dense Sensory Organ
Just three layers under the skin sit multiple mechanoreceptors, each responding to different types of force. Youâre not just shocking âmuscleââyouâre shocking a sophisticated sensory matrix.
Pacinian Corpuscles
⢠Detect vibration and sudden pressure
⢠These fire off immediately during a shock burst
Merkel Disks
⢠Detect deep pressure and object shapes
⢠Overload affects body awareness and posture regulation
Ruffini Endings
⢠Track skin stretch and limb position
⢠Critical for balance and motor control
⢠Disruption here throws off the dogâs whole 3D awareness system
Now imagine all of these firing at once. Thatâs not âclarity.â
Thatâs impulse chaos.
Impulse Chaos = Trauma
Your dogâs brain receives:
⢠Vibration (Pacinian)
⢠Deep stretch (Ruffini)
⢠Sudden pressure (Merkel)
⢠Neck-region nerve signals (vagus, accessory, cervical)
All pulsing into the spinal cord and brainstem simultaneously.
The result?
Fight. Flight. Or Freeze.
The dog doesnât get more âfocusedââthey get more hypervigilant, disconnected, or frozen. What looks like obedience is often just shutdown.
And Then Comes the Anticipation
Dogs are associative. After the first shock, they start bracing for the next.
This is anticipatory anxiety, and itâs biologically worse than the first zap.
The body floods with cortisol before the button is even pushed. The vagus nerve preps for threat. The limbic system locks into survival mode.
Youâre not training anymore.
Youâre rewiring the dog to live in fear of their own leash, collar, and handler.
Bottom Line: This Is Not âCommunicationâ
If a therapist zapped you in the neckâtriggering your breathing, heartbeat, posture, skin sensors, and head control all at onceâyouâd sue them.
Youâd call it trauma.
Because thatâs what it is.
And no, trying it on your arm doesnât count.
Your arm isnât your throat.
Youâre not a dog.
And you donât live in a constant state of trying to read the world without language.
This Isnât a Training Tool. Itâs a Nervous System Disruptor.
Stop calling it âlow level.â
Stop calling it âjust like TENS.â
Stop calling it humane.
Because when you press that button, youâre not sending a message.
You donât send your location, you donât sell the dogs problem, you simply add another problem up top of the existing problem your dog has.
Youâre setting off a biological fire alarm inside a being who cannot explain their fear.
Addendum (not so minor):
Letâs not forget the hair follicle, a fourth mechanoreceptor often overlooked in these discussions. In dogs, each follicle is connected to three hairs, and their skinâespecially in the neck regionâis densely furred and highly sensitive. These follicles detect even subtle vibrations. Critically, the first nerve relay for this haptic input doesnât stop at the spinal cord; it travels to a specialized nucleus just above it. In carnivorous mammals like dogs, this nucleus is larger and more complex than in humans or primates, meaning the same âlow-levelâ input can trigger a heightened full-body response. When you activate a shock collar, youâre not just touching skinâyouâre sending a chaotic signal through a neurologically supercharged system evolved for hunting, not handling pain.
(Dr. Sophie Savel, personal communication, May 14, 2025) thank youđ