05/11/2025
The word “tool” has almost become a dirty word in dog training.
But when you think about it, everything we use is a tool. A lead, a harness, a crate, a slip, an e-collar, a prong, they’re all tools. They’re simply different ways we communicate and create structure.
It’s not the tool that defines the experience. It’s how and why it’s used.
Somewhere along the way, tools became synonymous with punishment, something harsh or unfair. But the reality is far more nuanced.
There are times when I’ll reach for a tool straight away, like when a dog is chasing stock or has no recall and is putting themselves or other animals in danger. In those moments, it’s about safety first. Even then, I still teach the recall first, but the tool is introduced much faster, so the dog gains clarity before the behaviour becomes more dangerous or rehearsed.
In every other case, preparation comes first.
Before a correction ever happens, the dog is skilled up, they learn what cues mean, how to respond to pressure, how to turn it off, and what “yes” and “no” truly mean. Only then does a correction become fair.
If I tell my son, “Don’t cross the road,” he understands because he’s been taught what that means. When I say it again as he steps forward, he recognises it instantly, no fear, just clarity.
But if a child touches a hot stove without warning, that’s confusion, pain, and mistrust. The same happens when we correct a dog that hasn’t been prepared.
When a dog understands the foundation first, their body knows what to do with that information. The correction doesn’t shut them down, it refines their understanding. It becomes part of the dialogue, not a punishment.
Before I hand a tool over, I always make sure the dog and the owner are ready. Timing, pressure, and reinforcement all matter. Because when done correctly, tools don’t take away a dog’s joy or freedom, they create it.
The issue isn’t the tool itself. It’s when it’s handed over without education or purpose. When people rely on it to stop behaviour without understanding why it’s happening or what they’re communicating. That’s when you see fallout.
So maybe the conversation shouldn’t be “ tools.” Maybe it should be about the clarity, preparation, and intention behind them.