04/30/2024
CW: animal cruelty
(Image courtesy of Google Gemini)
Like most animal lovers, I’ve read the accounts of Kristi Noem’s story of shooting her juvenile dog Cricket with a mixture of shock, horror, and anger. Cricket was set up to fail and lost her life for it.
Noem took Cricket, a poorly trained/untrained juvenile into a large, open space, let her off leash, and got mad at her for doing what energetic puppies do. When Noem began to shock her (probably at the highest setting), Cricket did what any reasonable dog would in that situation: run away from the hostile person. Maybe Noem saw this as an affront to her authority, and it made her angrier. When she left, instead of properly securing her dogs in her vehicle, Cricket was able to get free, chase more birds (something she was bred to do), and killed a few. When Noem finally caught up to her, Cricket responded to an angry person grabbing her roughly with a bite, a perfectly normal reaction in this situation. Any dog will bite when cornered and fearing for their safety, no matter how good they are. That wasn’t an aggressive dog, that’s a frightened one.
I don’t blame Noem for being angry and embarrassed in that situation. I think most people would be. She claims that a story like this shows she’s willing to do the dirty work. She’s wrong. We might agree that she needed to make damn sure that Cricket never chased and killed chickens again, but it’s easy to shoot a dog and be done with it. It’s much harder to look your failure in the eyes every day while you make slow and steady training progress, or find a suitable home for her. That’s the real, hard, dirty work that should have been done. Kindness and compassion are incredibly hard when we feel offended or hurt. It’s a vile story and people like her should never be in power.
Her excuse that this was 20 years ago doesn’t cut it. That would have been around 2004. For context, Spirit and Opportunity landed on Mars in 2004. A landmark paper came out comparing training methods and the outcomes for dogs (spoiler alert: +R led to better outcomes than +P). Dr. Sophia Yin published her book “How to Behave So That Your Dog Behaves” that year, and both Petsmart and Petco’s training programs were rooted in positive reinforcement by then. We knew better. She knew better.