06/25/2022
My thoughts on store bought dog foods.
This is meant to be informative and educational. There is a lot of bad marketing and misinformation when it comes to store bought dog food, and to keep this short I will not go into a raw diet or a mixed raw and kibble diet.
When you’re choosing a dog food what it really comes down to is knowing how to read the ingredient label on the bag and how to read in between the lines. I’m going to use Purina Pro Plan Puppy as an example of GREAT advertising and marketing with BAD ingredients. Ill break this down on why this is not a good food.
Ingredients: Lamb, Rice, Chicken By-Product Meal, Corn Gluten Meal, Whole Grain Corn, Beef Fat Preserved With Mixed-tocopherols, Corn Germ Meal, Oat Meal, Dried Egg Product, Natural Flavor, Fish Meal, Dried Beet Pulp, Fish Oil, Calcium Carbonate, and a mix of vitamins and supplements after is standard in most kibble.
At first glance you see Lamb and chicken and think you’re doing great. The only standard these large corporations have to follow legally is that they have to list the ingredients in order of quantity by weight, high to low, and a guaranteed analysis of protein, fat, carbs etc. They can put anything else on the bag and as long as they have some scummy vet say it’s true they probably won’t get sued.
Lamb seems great, and it may be a good quality meat, but coming from Purina it’s probably the lowest quality imported meat they can find. Rice is fine for dogs, and being the second ingredient it’s not bad, but still it’s the second in the list and has a low protein and high carb ratio with very little nutrition available. The next ingredient is Chicken by product meal. This is what is left over from a whole chicken after they take out ALL the meat, then they take out all the stuff that goes into low quality hot dogs and canned meats (the good organs and fats). What’s left is literally skulls, feet, intestines, and the like. Anytime you see the words by-product meal after a protein this is what you’re getting. The next 3 out of 4 ingredients are some type of corn. The ONLY reason they have 3 different types of corn products is so they DO NOT have to list corn as the FIRST ingredient! This is why I don’t trust these big corporations for my dog food. This is marketing at its worst and a loophole to get around our FDAs almost nonexistent pet food regulations. You’re buying a bag of corn and rice with a few scoops of lamb and chicken intestines. Mix in some inexpensive vitamins and supplements and call it a premium dog food because lamb and chicken are on their fancy bag. It’s a shame they get away with this and if you’re using a dog food like this know that for not much more money you can feed them a much higher quality food. I understand and have even fed these foods before when I was a lot younger, but for the price of one take out meal a month you can feed a much higher quality food and your dog will thank you for it. You will end up spending the money at the vet to try and fix the problems these food can cause in the long run.
The worst offender to date…. Hills science diet, they even trick you in the name. They are the true marketing masters, they have even convinced most vets to push their products. Corn and soy in a food for overweight carnivores? Yes that’s true! Here are the first ingredients in their DIET food -
Chicken Meal, Cracked Pearled Barley, Pea Fiber, Whole Grain Wheat, Whole Grain Corn, Corn Gluten Meal, Whole Grain Sorghum, Powdered Cellulose, Chicken Liver Flavor, Soybean Oil! Oh any you only have to feed them 5 cups a day to keep the weight off! All while they develop an allergy to wheat, don’t worry they have a food for that as well...
A higher quality dog food would be something like Taste of the Wild, Merrik, and Canidae. These foods are generally affordable and provide much higher quality actual nutrition and are not a bag of fillers like corn, soy, and wheat. We started feeding Canidae all life stages switching from a grain free food last year. Grain free foods are fine, but there has been some issues with heart problems in certain breeds eating grain free that we decided not to take any risk until we get better information and studies done to decide if it is safe to feed. Bulldogges and bully breeds were not affected so far. These food are not what I consider the most optimal food to feed but as a breeder I want to raise our dogs on a diet the average dog owner would be able to feed economically and low effort to make them more available to the average person. And to know that our dogs can go to homes without major changes that most people do not want to deal with. We also supplement with whole chicken, turkey, eggs and other raw ingredients and supplements.
To go a step further, a raw diet with whole animal parts, organ meats, mixed with raw veggies and supplements would be the best way to feed a dog. This can get expensive and time consuming. There are also some dangers to raw feeding and this should be achievable and safe if you educate yourself on raw and barf diets. YouTube has countless videos on these types of feeding with complete how-tos.
If you just want to get away from the bad dog foods follow these rules: Do not buy your dog food from a grocery store. Do Not buy from the big corporations like Purina, Mars, Nestle, and Hills. Read the ingredients list.
Remember these companies pay billions in advertising to manipulate your buying choices unethically. Even to google to make sure you cannot easily find smaller websites that will have negative reviews.
Thanks for taking the time to read if you have any questions
Please ask in the comments and we will do our best answer compassionate or send me a message!
Jeff and Stephanie Freeman
Barkleys Bulldogges