
11/17/2024
Consent and why it can be very useful and very impractical has been on my mind lately. I am working with a feral dog that was born in confinement and kept there. When the dog was taken outside, he was dragged along the ground on a harness and not taught to walk. While the people at the facility probably thought they were helping him, this created more adversity to a leash than if they never took him for a “walk” If I waited for consent from this dog to walk on a leash, it may take years to his lifetime and that is time wasted he could be walking in a park. While Waiting for consent the dog is building stronger habits of NOT walking and resisting the leash altogether. Dogs lives are short. How much time is humane to let dogs not be a dog while waiting for consent?
The dog also has NO concept of the choice he is making when he doesn’t want to walk on a leash. The dog doesn’t understand that if he walks on a leash, he will be able to exercise, sniff, run, and just fulfill his dogness. He has never experienced these things in a leash so he has no idea the leash means freedom and fun. We cannot explain it to him. He is a dog. We can only SHOW him. And to show him what he is missing we have to actually get him outside. Even then, since he has never been outside on leash while having a positive experience, he still won’t understand the choice for a few walks at least.
So is it even fair to put this decision on a dog that cannot comprehend what the consequences of his choice is? Or is waiting for consent a way for people to skirt the sometimes unpleasant choice of doing what is best for the dog in our human world? Is waiting for consent just taking the responsibility, and therefore any blame if it doesn’t work, off of us? Is waiting for consent actually fear of taking action and messing up the dog?
As usual I think we can find the best path in the middle ground. There is always a place when working with feral and fearful dogs, and all dogs, where they can experience some stress or unpleasantness and then learn that thing is actually good. This may be through many avenues and with this dog I am using cream cheese in a spoon combined with a harness. This is for the dog’s success and also the owner’s comfort. This is also all over zoom so I can’t be there in person to guide. There is a happy space of the dog expanding his world and trust in his handler by doing slightly challenging tasks together.
Just to be clear, forcing a dog, like dragging the dog, is not that happy space. I may put tension on a leash for a second, but then the dog learns how to release it and therefore gains confidence. I may use a leash to have the dog go out the door, but then the dog gets outside and decides he likes to be outside so then he can actually make the choice to go outside. (Classical conditioning and learning how to control things improves dogs confidence and is proven in many studies but I don’t recall the sources at the moment)
Dogs are curious and open to improving their situation. They are genetically programmed to handle stressful situations and adversity and then learn the situation actually benefits them. By us not allowing the dog to use these innate skills and resiliency are we being true to the dog?(That trash can the dog knocks over makes a lot of noise, but the dog comes back for food and learns by classical conditioning the trash can noise is a good one. This is essential for survival of many dogs in the world). But sometimes our human parameters and ideas like consent get in the dog’s way. Reasonableness needs to be present in dog training again.