21/04/2022
I have tried to explain this to my clients but this post explains it to perfection.
For all of you who’ve been taught that corrections/punishment will destroy the relationship between you and your dog, and who now believe this, and are terrified to do so—let me introduce you to what you’ve not been taught.
Reality.
The reality of how your dog perceives you, and the association and relationship that develops from that perception, comes from ALL your interactions.
As I shared in the original graphic, if you were to ONLY engage in a one dimensional interaction dynamic, where you ONLY corrected/punished your dog, then you actually would undermine your relationship.
But unless you’re a sadist, I can’t imagine you’re taking on a dog only to correct/punish it. So you can relax those relationship fears. If you’re like any of the thousands of owners I’ve interacted with, you do many things with your dog—many things that have nothing to do with a negative associations. Things like I shared in the graphic: walks, play, affection, feeding, car rides, adventures etc.
When you share a multi-faceted relationship dynamic; one that is balanced with far more positive, fun, rewarding, enjoyable interactions, along with the occasional correction/punishment—which shouldn’t be fun or enjoyable—your healthy relationship is safe and sound. Your association is a healthy, balanced one. It’s both positive and negative, with the positives far outweighing the negatives.
This is why vets have it so tough. Your vet is almost always going to get the single dimensional association. Even when owners attempt to counter this association, bringing their dogs to the vet for non-visits, and having the staff give treats and pets...the scary, stressful, and sometimes painful reality of the other visits far outweigh the other positive interactions, and aren’t nearly powerful enough or frequent enough to combat the negative experience most dogs go through with typical vet visits. And so, we see the shaking, quaking, stressed out, freaked out behavior when we visit.
But back to you. Along with what I’ve shared above about relationship balance, your dog also learns that it controls its reality. It finds that negative consequences only occur when they make poor choices. Which means you are predictable in your actions, which means your dog’s world is predictable and safe...even when faced with undesirable consequences which come from you. Your dog understands that the consequences are tied to their behavior, and are anything but random. Which is also why the entire silliness about “learned helplessness” (which is also leveraged to frighten owners) is also precisely that…silliness. If your dog understands that their choices control their world, they’re anything but helpless. But that’s a topic for another day.
To sum up, if you live a normal, multi-faceted life with your dog, like everyone I’ve seen, you won’t have any fallout from correcting/punishing your dog. Zip, zero, nada. In fact, if you do a little thinking, you’ll see how easily owners accidentally create a truly dysfunctional, toxic, unhealthy relationship...by ONLY engaging in positives. Yep, you guessed it. You’ve become a one dimensional owner. One who need not be listened to, respected, or appropriately interacted with. Is that a positive association? Is that a healthy relationship?It’s certainly not how I’d define either, and it’s certainly not what I’d want for me or my dog.
Strangely, they always seem to leave these inconvenient truths out of the conversation. I wonder why?