09/08/2024
“Whether you are new to Rescue or have been doing it for years, it's something you definitely need to think about. You need to think about it before it happens, because it will happen and you need to know what you are going to be able to do.” Read this in its entirety. ❤️
Sick Cats – the TNR moral dilemma
Who goes into cat rescue? I would guess the vast majority are people who care very passionately about the cats, wanting to be able to improve their lives. And through TNR, we are able to help so many cats live better healthier lives - but when you are doing Rescue and one of those cats is very sick – what do you do? Or when he has a physical condition that is going to inevitably lead to a painful death unless he gets expensive veterinary care? Or maybe she has a physical disability that is not life-threatening, but will put her at a much higher risk of death by predator if she is returned to her site?
For those of us who have been involved in Rescue for many years, these scenarios are sadly not that uncommon. But whether you are new to Rescue or have been doing it for years, it's something you definitely need to think about. You need to think about it before it happens, because it will happen and you need to know what you are going to be able to do.
The problem for so many rescuers is when they are facing the reality of a cat who needs help, but is going to end up costing hundreds or thousands of dollars and needing a place to stay and recover and foster. There are some people who have plenty of money and are able to take on extremely expensive rescues, but the majority of us simply cannot afford to spend hundreds or thousands of dollars on a single Rescue cat. And yet they suffer tremendous guilt – nobody likes to be the one to say "euthanize this cat" – we're here to save cats not kill them. The reality though is you need to look at the word euthanize - "Euthanasia is the practice of ending the life of a patient to limit the patient's suffering".
If you have a cat without an owner living outside, and you trap it to do TNR and it turns out to have a terminal condition, you are faced with
1– taking on expensive veterinary care and prolonged foster situation,
2 – choosing to euthanize the cat to prevent more suffering, or
3-returning it to the site with no treatment.
Option 1 – because so many rescuers have gone deeply into debt and have ended up in deep trouble, we highly encourage rescuers to consider 2 things - their own situation before spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on this one cat, and 2 - the chances for a good long-term outcome. What will this cat's quality of life be?
Option 2 - euthanasia. This is a difficult decision for most people, and we appreciate that. Ending a life should never be a casual decision or something chosen for convenience. But peacefully and humanely ending a life to prevent suffering is a kindness. Hopefully the veterinarian assessing this cat can help guide the rescuer to the right decision – while veterinarians don't like to euthanize the cats if they can avoid it, we hope they also recognize it's extremely painful to make that decision. We encourage veterinarians to help the rescuers be realistic during this emotional time.
Option 3 – returning the cat to the site untreated. We hope no one would return a cat who was doomed to a painful ending of life without treatment, but the thought of making the decision to euthanize is so difficult for so many that they will choose to do nothing rather than to make the choice. Once again talking this through with your veterinarian can hopefully bring a more detached viewpoint, and the ability to recognize that in the end it is a selfish thing to return a cat that you know is going to die a bad death; it protects your feelings, you don't have to take responsibility for having ended the life. But Rescue is all about responsibility – and when you return the cat without treating or euthanizing, but knowing there's a problem, you are still making a choice - and you are still responsible.
Rescue is full of so much joy, and it is full of so much heartache as well. We all need to be supportive of each other in making these difficult choices, and should not ever impose guilt or shame on anyone who makes the decision to euthanize to help prevent suffering. Do your best to be supportive and work together on these decisions – the rescuer, the caregiver, the veterinarian, your fellow rescuers – work together to create a compassionate and realistic understanding of what Rescue truly is.
(***** We are NOT recommending casual euthanasia. Just an understanding of your own financial and emotional needs as well as the needs of the animal.)