12/03/2020
Color Genetics
Part 1
One of the first things we notice and usually the first thing we fall in love with about our dogs is their coat color. And just about everyone has a favorite color in their breed. I personally love the chocolate coat color, also known as liver in other breeds. But no matter what the name for the color is, there is much more to color than meets they eye.
An important reason to know at least the base of color genetics is to breed safely. There are some color or patterns that should never be bred together and some that are known to have health issues associated with them.
In this and the next few posts, I will go over the base of color genetics that I believe every breeder should know. I will try to keep it simple and try to include as many pictures as I can. So please bare with me as I am still learning.
There are 2 types of pigment, Eumelanin and Phaeomelanin. The pigment is what gives the hair its color. All coat colors and patterns are created with these 2 pigments and each has a "default" color that can be modified by various genes.
Eumelanin
This pigment's default color is black. There are genes that turn eumelanin into other colors-liver(chocolate), blue(grey) or isabella(also known as lilac in some breeds). If the dog has any of the genes that turn black pigment into liver, blue or isabella. Eumelanin is also present in other areas that needs pigment like the eyes and nose. Only Eumelanin can affect the nose and eyes.
So the default color of eumelanin is black but it can be turned into liver. Black and liver can be diluted to be blue and isabella.
Phaeomelanin
This pigments default is red. "Red" covers everything from a light cream to a deep red like in an Irish setter. Phaeomelanin is only produced in the coat, not the eyes or nose.
The following are the loci associated with color
A (agouti)
K (dominate black)
B (brown)
D (dilute)
E (extension)
M (Merle)
H (harlequin)
S (spotting)
T (ticking and roaning)
G (graying)
A(sable, agouti/wolf grey, tan points, saddles/creeping tan, recessive black)
The agouti or A loci has 4 known alleles: ay-sable, aw-agouti or wolf grey, at-tan points, and a-recessive black. This loci controls the cells that produce eumelanin. The A loci can only be expressed if the dog has one of the following genotpyes on the K locus: k/k, k/kbr or kbr/kbr. k/kbr and kbr/kbr will add brindle on top of any phaeomelanin areas. If the dog has just one K allele then it will be solid black, liver, blue or isabella depending what is carried on the D locus. A dominate black dog(carrying one K allele) may genetically be sable, tan point or agouti but will not express it.
Lets look a little deeper....
Ay-Sable
Ay, or sable is the most dominate in the A loci, so being the most dominate a dog only needs one sable(ay) allele to express it. There are 3 types of "patterns" that can modify sable (which has yet to be identified as of yet), clear sable, tipped sable, and shaded sable.
Clear sable are completely red dogs. They can be almost impossible to distinguish from recessive red dogs unless they have a mask, which never appears on recessive red dogs. If there is any black, liver, blue or isabella in the coat at all the must be sable rather than recessive red. (recessive red dogs cannot produce any eumelanin). Clear sable is most commonly known as fawn.
Tipped sable are red dogs with black, liver, blue or isabella hairs. They usually have these hairs on their back, head, tail and ears. Most tipped sables have a mask.
Shaded sables overlap the tipped sables and red dogs with brown and black hairs covering the top of the head, ears, and back. The shading can be very light to vary dark and they have "widow's peak" on the forehead where the dark hair forms a point, kind of like Micky mouse. Shaded sables can also be blue, liver and isabella. In some breeds shaded sables are known as S**t.
aw-agouti/wolf grey
Agouti is mostly seen in the breeds that are closely related to the wolves as well as some northern breeds. In its normal form, agouti can look almost identical to shaded sable. The difference is banded hairs. Banded hairs means the fur is growing, first the cells produce the pigment and then they switch to another type, usually phaeomelanin. The gene then tells the cells to switch back to the pigment. So you end up with a hair the for example is black then white then black again. Agouti also tends to follow the same pattern as tan points with a nose bar instead of widows peak.
When combined with phaeomelanin dilution, agouti becomes much more distinctive as the red hairs then become cream to grayish.
Another thing to remember is when a German Shepherd is called sable, they are actually agouti.
at-tan points
Tan points are at the bottom of the recessive A loci. This means that a dog must have 2 copies of the tan point gene to express it. Tan point is one of the most well known marking and they appear above the eyes, sides on the muzzle and extend to the cheeks, pips on the cheeks, the front of the chest, on the lower legs and feet and the insides of the legs and a patch under the tail. Most commonly known to be paired with black but can also be paired with liver, blue and isabella. Black markings on the toes is called penciling.
Sometimes tan points can be covered up by a mask, depending on how far that masks extends, you my still be able to see the tan points above the eyes.
The saddle pattern and creeping tan are thought to modifiers of the tan point gene, although the modifier has yet to be located. The saddle and creeping tan modifiers causes the eumelanin on the dog to "retreat" to the dogs back only leaving the rest of the coat "tan". A dog with creeping tan is slightly more red or tan than normal tan pointed dogs. The saddle pattern is the next step after creeping tan and the red/tan extends over the whole head, the front of the neck and chest and the top of the legs, only leaving the black (or other eumelanin color) on the back, back of the neck and tail.
Saddle and creeping tan dogs are usually born black and tan (or any other eumelanin) and the black recedes as the dog grows. These patterns are most commonly seen in hounds, terriers, and German Shepherd Dogs.
a-recessive black
Recessive black is a rare gene and only occurs in a handful of breeds like German Shepherd Dog, Shetland Sheepdog, Puli and Samoyed. These dogs are unable to make any phaeomelanin pigment. A dog needs 2 recessive black genes to be recessive black. The only difference in dominate black and recessive black are in breeding. A solid black puppy maybe born from parents who are non-solid black if they both carry 1 copy of the recessive black gene(they will not express it). A dominate black puppy can only be born if one or both parents are also dominate black. The recessive black gene is on a different locus as the dominate black gene, making it the only way that a dog can still be born solid black if it is kk(non-solid black) on the K locus. Both recessive black and dominate black look the same.
Something to note is that above I stated that Samoyed are recessive black, but the dog appears white. This is because here, it is combined with other alleles, which dilute or remove the pigment.
K(dominate black, brindle, seal,"ghost" tan)
There are 2 basic markings for dogs, solid-no red/ tan markings or non-solid-red /tan marking of any sort. Whether a dog is solid or non-solid depends entirely on the K locus. K has 3 alleles:K-dominate black, sometimes referred to as KB, kbr-brindle, and k-recessive non-black.
K-dominate black
Because K is dominate black a dog only needs one K allele and they will be solid black. This color can be changed to liver, blue or isabella or even Merle. Any dog with even one K allele will not be able to express anything on the A locus. For example, a dog may be genetically sable or tan point but because it is K/k or K/K on the K locus this dog will look solid black (or liver, blue, isabella or Merle). The only way for phaeomelanin(red) can be added to the coat of dominate black gene dog is through the E locus(recessive red). This will turn dominate black dogs(or any dog) into a solid red dog with a black pigment. A great example of a dominate black dog is the black lab. They have no red coloring in their coat. A chocolate lab is also dominate black only this dog carries the liver gene so his coat is brown. A yellow lab is also dominate black but carries recessive red which changes his coat color. A yellow lab with a brown nose also carries the liver gene and if he did not carry recessive red, he too would be a chocolate lab.
kbr-brindle
A dog with 1 or 2 kbr alleles will express whichever allele is on the A locus, but all phaeomelanin or red in the coat will be brindle. So for example, a solid brindle dog will be ay/ay on the A locus. A dog with brindle points will be at/at on the A locus, this is commonly known as trindle. These dogs will only have the brindle expressed on the tan points because brindle can only affect the red coloring.
Brindle usually appears as black stripes on a red base. The stripes are eumalanin and the base is phaeomelanin. Eumalanin can be affected by Merle, harlequin, liver, dilute, graying and recessive red, so those pigments can be changes to any of those genes. Phaeomelanin can be affected by intensity locus, making the base lighter or darker. Any white or ticking can also occur on any brindle dog as well.
Liver and dilute can also affect brindle. A dog that is b/b on the B locus will have brown stripes. A dog that is d/d on the D locus will have blue stripes and a dog who is both d/d and b/b with have isabella stripes.
Since both brindle and Merle only affect the eumalanin areas or a dog, any brindle that appears to be broken up into shorter stripes and spots may be a Merle.
Seal
Seal is currently a mystery. There is no genetic research so far conducted into seal. It is unknown how it is caused or which locus is responsible for it. Theories include seal being an allele on the K locus, recessive to K, potentially something like a faulty K allele that works similar to brindle, an allele on the A locus, or a modifier on an unknown locus that's causes A locus to partly show through on K/k dogs.
Seal coloring makes a black dog appear brownish with the pigment of the eyes and nose renaming black. The shades vary from slight brown to a shade almost as light as liver. There is usually a black stripe down the back and tail as well as the legs and they usually remain darker then the main part of the body. Seal dogs are born brownish and develop bronzing with age.
"Ghost" Tan
Ghost tan is thought to work similar to seal, where the K allele for some reason allows the A locus allele(s) to show through very faintly. A ghost tan dog would look like a normal tan point dog if the dominate K allele wasn't present.