30/06/2022
Herding dogs! I am a little bit biased, but this is my favourite group. And a lot of dog trainers feel the same way, because, well, to be honest...herding dogs make us look good! Their rapt attention, responsiveness, and intense drive to 'do stuff' in partnership with a human makes them a joy to train in many ways. It does NOT, however, make them "easy" dogs! Especially not for the average family lifestyle.
Herding dogs are one of the most fascinating chapters in the human-dog partnership saga. In order to manage our domesticated prey animals, we harnessed the instincts and appearance of the predator: the wolf helping us move the lamb. It started out with some primitive Asian and Spitz breeds who could chase and bark at the stock to move or hold them, without attacking them. As we continued selecting the best dogs for the job, we continued to refine, sharpen, modify, and mute parts of the natural predatory sequence (orient > eye-stalk > chase > grab-bite > kill-bite > dissect > consume.) It was a razor's edge that we were walking with these dogs. We wanted a heightened instinct for stalking and chasing movement, and sometimes we wanted an inhibited grab-bite. But we definitely didn't want these dogs to kill or eat our livestock! And it was absolutely critical that they have the ability, even when highly aroused, to attend to and respond to our cues. At the same time, we needed hardy, rugged dogs who were suited to the terrain we were working them in, and had the stamina to go all day, but also the off-switch to stop when we said "that'll do." (Note: because it's such a thin razor's-edge of selections, there were always—and still are—dogs who retained more of the predatory instinct than we wanted. So it's a mistake to assume that if you get a herding breed, your dog would never chase and kill livestock. Genetics are not predictive, but the majority of dogs will fall somewhere close to the intended selections, with standard deviation.)
As time went on, we continued to adapt and hone these dogs for different types of stock and different environments. In comparatively recent history, some of these dogs left their pastoral roots behind for a different type of work. Because they were so responsive to human direction, even in high-stakes environments, and because they had such a strong work-ethic and are highly-attuned to their environment, certain breeds and lines within breeds were adapted for military, police, and security purposes. These dogs underwent additional modification and selective pressures. For instance, more emphasis on the bite.
Because of all the variety within the herding group, it's really important to look into the history of your dog's breed (or predominant breed, in the case of a mixed-breed dog.) There are going to be key differences between the average Australian Shepherd and the average Belgian Malinois, for example. But beyond the breed, it is also helpful if you know the lines, especially when you're choosing a puppy. You could have four dogs that you would almost think were different breeds, but they're actually all Border Collies: it's just that one was bred for a cattle ranch, one for sheep trials, one for agility, and one for AKC conformation.
But despite all the variations, there will be some key similarities. At their core, herding dogs are bred to be sensitive to movement and any contrasts or changes in the environment. While depending on the intended job, we may have valued more or less independence and decision-making ability, herding dogs are on the whole bred to work in closer cooperation with humans than, for instance, a livestock guardian dog, which means they do tend to be quite handler-focused and "tuned-in" with their person.
They are regulators. They want law-and-order, they want all the boxes checked, they want the ducks in a row. If anything changes, they'll let you know about it. You might think it's insignificant that the neighbour parked on a different side of the street than she usually does, but your herding dog still thought you'd like to know.
A lot of people say herding dogs are bossy, but that's not entirely accurate. In truth, they are often relieved to take a back seat—but they're always standing ready to step in whenever they perceive that no one is competently driving the bus. They're not going to let this thing crash on their watch. As long as you're a competent driver and you honour them by providing clear and consistent information about the world, and involve them by giving them clearly-defined tasks and expectations, your herding dog is happy to let you keep the wheel. The ideal human for a herding dog has clearly outlined procedures, precedents, and parameters outlined. Write an employee handbook for your herding dog—a literal one, if that helps you. She'll be that employee that can quote it back to you and let you know if you didn't dot an 'i' or cross a 't.'
In short, your herding dog was designed to be your partner in everything, and she craves that. Type-A is written in her DNA, and she will struggle in a chaotic or disorderly environment. Having a herding dog often feels like having a gifted toddler: coming up with activities for her, driving her to her sports and classes, and helping her navigate her big feelings can be a huge time, money, and energy commitment. These dogs are not for everyone. But for some of us (perhaps ourselves herding dogs at heart), we can't possibly imagine a better adventure buddy, work partner, and friend than our herding dogs provide.
✨ Please show off your Herding Dogs in the comments!! Bonus points for shots of them in action.
Next up: Gun dogs! Keep an eye out.
***Note! The information in these graphics is an extremely brief overview, and the breeds listed are just examples. There are many other breeds which fall into this category. For a deeper dive, definitely research the specific history of the individual breed you are considering, or already have in your home! Also, please remember that genetics are not predictive. They just give us a good idea of what is more likely; an idea of what we shouldn't be surprised to see. Remember that the dog's Learning and Environment also have a role to play, and at the end of the day, each dog is their own unique Self.
Have a mixed breed dog and not sure whether it's a Herding Dog? Check out https://www.thedogkey.com/index.html, which can narrow down which group your dog is most likely to fall into.
Credit to Kim Brophey, who created the LEGS® model and the system of 10 genetic groups.
Resources:
THE DOG'S TRUTH - the ground-breaking new course that pulls back the curtain on "the truth that every dog lover on earth needs to know in order to do right by their own canine companions and those they work with professionally." (Every Apt Canine training/behaviour client gets FREE access!) Watch the trailer here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUPZQqJxbDQ
Genomic Analyses Reveal the Influence of Geographic Origin, Migration, and Hybridization on Modern Dog Breed Development
- https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28445722/