01/12/2024
I was walking Stormy the other day when a neighbor pulled over, rolled down the window, and attempted a conversation with me. Her dog was in the backseat barking at us which, accompanied by my neighbor's occasional yelling at her dog to be quiet, made conversing very difficult. I told her, "He's fine, just let him bark." She looked me dead in the eye, said "It's NOT fine", and carried on alternatively conversing/yelling until she gave up and said she'd text me later.
In behavioral science, the definition of positive punishment is adding an undesirable consequence (yelling) after an unwanted behavior (barking) to decrease the chance that the behavior (barking) will happen again. The very definition of training using punishment includes a change in the behavior. Did her dog stop barking at us when the owner yelled at him? No. If there is no behavior change, it's not training. I wouldn't go so far as to call it abuse, but it's certainly mean-spirited, ineffective, and completely unnecessary. So what's a girl to do? Seriously, just let the dog bark. He wasn't hurting anything - he was literally doing what humanity had spent millenia breeding him to do, alert his owner to a nearby stranger. If their house gets broken into at night and the dog doesn't bark, I bet she'll be really mad!
I get it, it's frustrating. I catch myself doing it too. Briar has recently been diagnosed with Cushing's disease, which makes him hungry constantly. And when he's hungry, he cries. Constantly. Is it obnoxious? Absolutely! Is yelling at him going to make him less hungry? Of course not. (Especially since he's deaf anyway.) All I'm doing is working myself up over it. When I catch myself getting mad over it, I breathe, let it go, and put on my noise-cancelling headphones. Seriously, those things are worth their weight in gold.
Now, I'm not saying excessive barking is okay. What I'm saying is that there is a reason dogs bark and it's up to the owner to determine if that reason is valid or not. Whether it's a valid reason (being hungry) or not (barking at friendly strangers), THE UNDERLYING PROBLEM NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED, NOT THE BARKING ITSELF. The best way to get Briar to stop whining? Feed him. Give him his meds as prescribed. Solve the problem he's complaining about. The best way to stop dogs from barking at strangers? Teach them that strangers are friends. Or train them "speak" and "hush". Or give them the physical and mental exercise they're lacking. The barking is just a symptom - figure out why they're barking and solve the problem. And in the meantime, just let the dog bark.
*I do not own the comic, but it certainly fits!