20/06/2025
𝗪𝗵𝘆 𝗜 𝗡𝗘𝗩𝗘𝗥 𝗥𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗺𝗲𝗻𝗱 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗨𝘀𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝗣𝘂𝗻𝗶𝘀𝗵𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁?
Apart from the fact that it simply makes no sense to cause fear, pain, anxiety and distress to someone we love whether they are a horse, dog, other animal or person we love? I completely understand that sometimes we all lose our temper and act in ways we later regret but punishment will never be the answer to anything. Decades of research exists explaining why punishment is both damaging and the most ineffective way to teach anyone anything (Gershoff,2010, McGreevy & McLean,2009, Daniels et al,2022,Henshall et al,2022). In learning theory terms a “punisher” decreases a behaviour response and makes it less likely to be repeated in future in those circumstances and a “reinforcer” increases the likelihood of a behaviour being repeated in those circumstances in the future (McGreevy & McLean,2009).
Positive punishment is the addition of an aversive stimulus such as hitting, smacking, shouting at your horse or dog and negative punishment is the removal of something the horse or dog likes or enjoys like food or a toy. We absolutely should never be utilising physical affection such as touch or a scratch ONLY in a training context, provided the animal,enjoys these they should be available as part of our relationships and every day affiliative interactions with our animals not something they have to earn. Examples of withdrawals of affection might include pushing or smacking your horse for requesting a scratch or turning your back on your dog when they jump up.
Punishment is problematic because:
🐴🐶 It doesn't teach the individual what they should do instead.
🐴🐶It fails to address why the issue is occurring. Behaviour is multifaceted and we need to be addressing root cause including ensuring the animal is healthy and not in pain with all of their individual and species specific needs being met.
🐴🐶It suppresses the behaviour only for it to return with more vigour later. This is known as behaviour suppression and spontaneous recovery.
🐴🐶Fear (avoidance) increases or worsens
🐴🐶Aggression may increase or worsen.
🐴🐶It can create fear and aggression.
🐴🐶It can be traumatising for the individual who is being punished.
🐴🐶It requires a great deal of accuracy to apply without causing fall out, literally within seconds of the unwanted behaviour occurring for the horse or dog to make the connection between the behaviour and the punishment delivered. It also needs to be aversive enough and applied at the correct intensity. That said why would we want to punish those we love when kinder better ways exist?
🐴🐶The horse or dog can learn to suppress their behaviour in your presence but still display it if you are not there.
🐴🐶It can interfere with your horse or dogs’ ability to concentrate and learn due to them being fearful and stressed.
🐴🐶It is hugely damaging to the relationship you share with your horse or dog.
🐴🐶It can create negative and traumatic associations with people (including you), the environment, equipment and even the task itself.
Ultimately, why would we not want to have the best relationship possible and not frighten or harm our animals. There are other better and more humane ways to manage behaviours that we dislike or are undesirable.These include once their needs have been met, managing the environment so your horse or dog can not perform the behaviour such as using protected contact or the use of window film to reduce barking , ensuring all of their physical and emotional needs are being met including opportunities to meet their own needs such as for horses opportunities to scratch any itches by providing appropriate surfaces such as brush heads, door mat fixed to the wall or trees. In addition providing appropriate outlets for their natural behaviours such as a digging area to prevent digging in the garden.
Finally, it is far easier to prevent a problem from developing than it is to manage or prevent it once it has developed so please think twice before resorting to punishing your animals. As a Provisional Clinical Animal Behaviourist part of my role is to support people to stop any aversive equipment including rope, be kind, dually halters, chiffneys, slip leads prong and shock collars and improve their relationship with their horses and dogs. I recognise that often people resort to the use of punishment or aversive equipment from a place of fear, frustration and desperation as to what will help (Condon et al, 2022,Daniels et al,2022,Ijicni et al,2018).
At the end of the day even if positive reinforcement was less effective and it is in fact more effective, surely we would want to take a humane approach because we love our animals and don't wish to hurt them?
References
Condon, V. M., McGreevy, P. D., McLean, A. N., Williams, J. M., & Randle, H. (2022). Associations between commonly used apparatus and conflict behaviors reported in the ridden horse in Australia. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 49, 1-14.
Daniels, J. T., Busby, D., Chase-Topping, M., & Brown, S. M. (2023). A survey of dog behavior modification practice in the UK: Who is offering it, what methods are they using and how effective do their clients perceive practitioners to be?. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 59, 1-7.
Gershoff, E. T. (2010). More harm than good: A summary of scientific research on the intended and unintended effects of corporal punishment on children. Law and Contemporary Problems, 73(2), 31.
Henshall, C., Randle, H., Francis, N., & Freire, R. (2022). Habit Formation and the Effect of Repeated Stress Exposures on Cognitive Flexibility Learning in Horses. Animals, 12(20)
Ijichi, C., Wild, H., Dai, F., Bordin, A., Cameron-Whytock, H., White, S. J., ... & Dalla Costa, E. (2020). Dually investigated: The effect of a pressure headcollar on the behaviour, discomfort and stress of trained horses. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 232, 105101.
McGreevy, P. D., & McLean, A. N. (2009). Punishment in horse-training and the concept of ethical equitation. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 4(5), 193-197.
🐴🐶Provisional Clinical Animal Behaviourist and Family Dog Mediator supporting horses and dogs who are fearful, traumatised or who have complex needs
📍South East
WhatsApp 0776 331 7464
©️Jessie Sams Animal Behaviour and Trauma Recovery Service