Gary -Gaz- Jackson Dog Trainer, Author, Speaker

06/01/2025

06/01/2025

Always choose an experienced professional dog trainer not a force free ideologist. This is a great article.

The veterinary behavioural space, once rooted in the principles of rigorous scientific inquiry, has fallen victim to ideological capture. This phenomenon occurs when a particular belief system takes over, pushing aside alternative viewpoints and suppressing open debate. This is exactly what we’re seeing in how various influential organizations, such as the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), and the British Veterinary Association (BVA), have wholeheartedly embraced and promoted purely positive, force-free training methods. These organizations base their sweeping endorsements on studies that rely heavily on owner-reported surveys—data that, while useful for gauging public opinion, is far from the robust, empirical evidence needed to make definitive claims about dog training. This selective endorsement of flawed data reflects an ideological bias that not only undermines scientific integrity but also limits the options available to dog trainers and owners, ultimately to the detriment of the animals they seek to protect.

Owner-reported surveys are problematic because they capture perceptions rather than objective outcomes. These surveys are susceptible to various biases, such as the tendency for respondents to report what they think is the "correct" or socially accepted answer, rather than their true experience, and they rely on the owner’s ability (or, more commonly, the lack thereof) to accurately interpret their dog’s behaviour. This can lead to skewed results that do not accurately reflect the effectiveness of different training methods. Despite these well-known flaws, organizations that advocate for purely positive training present these surveys as ironclad evidence of their approach’s superiority. This is both misleading and a clear indication of ideological capture—where evidence is cherry-picked to support a predetermined narrative, rather than being evaluated on its merits.

What’s overlooked in these discussions is that the improper use of any training tool—whether it’s an e-collar, prong collar, no-pull harness, or head halter—can lead to unwanted behaviors or unnecessary stress in a dog. The key issue isn’t the tool itself, but how it is used. For instance, Dr. Richard Polsky’s study (2000) raises valid concerns about the potential for e-collars to cause aggression if used incorrectly. However, this risk is not unique to e-collars. Any tool, when misused, can lead to adverse outcomes. This is why skilled trainers emphasize the importance of using these tools responsibly, ensuring that the dog fully understands what is expected before any form of correction is introduced.

Trainers who advocate for a combination of positive reinforcement and aversive tools understand that no single method works for all dogs in all situations. They agree with purely positive trainers that new behaviours should be taught using positive reinforcement. However, they also recognize that some behaviours, particularly those that are dangerous or deeply ingrained, may require the careful and humane use of corrections to be effectively managed. This approach is supported by studies like Schalke et al. (2007), which found that e-collars, when used correctly by trained professionals, do not increase stress levels in dogs and can be an effective part of a comprehensive training strategy; though it should also be noted that avoidance of all stress is not necessarily a laudable training goal.

Despite this evidence, the lack of longitudinal studies that assess the long-term effects of different training methods on a dog’s overall quality of life remains a significant gap in the research. Most existing studies, especially those favouring purely positive methods, focus on immediate outcomes—the quality of the moment—without addressing how these methods impact a dog’s well-being over time - the quality of life. This is a critical oversight. Without long-term studies, the conclusions drawn from short-term surveys are at best incomplete and at worst, misleading.

The fact that these flaws are well-known but consistently ignored by purely positive advocates is further evidence of ideological capture. By promoting a narrow, ideologically driven view of dog training, these organizations risk leaving trainers and dog owners without the full range of tools necessary to address complex behavioural issues. This leads to negative outcomes for dogs, including increased frustration, persistent behavioural problems, and in extreme but increasingly common cases, the unnecessary euthanasia of dogs that could have been rehabilitated with a more comprehensive approach.

The ideological capture of the veterinary behavioural space, driven by a selective endorsement of flawed survey-based studies is a troubling trend and a direct threat to the well-being of the dogs these organizations are supposed to protect. It’s time to push back against this dogma and advocate for a more nuanced, evidence-based approach that considers all available data, including the long-term effects of different training methods themselves, as well as the long-term benefits of having been properly trained using aversive tools. Science demands open inquiry, rigorous testing, and a willingness to challenge prevailing assumptions. Anything less is not just unscientific—it’s a disservice to the animals in our care.

06/01/2025

The internets biggest dog training influencer con artist.

05/01/2025

The comments are gold. 😂

We studiously stay away from politics on this page, but this seems relevant. Zak George proudly supporting internationally recognized terrorist groups while accusing those of us who responsibly use aversive tools of being animal abusers is really… something. Speaks strongly to the quality of his character and makes a complete lie of the nice guy character he puts on in his videos. His darkness should be more widely known.

29/12/2024

Hahaha

26/12/2024

OMG this is hilarious, going on a date with a force free dog trainer, RUN 🤪
https://www.facebook.com/share/v/15r9W3YNex/?mibextid=wwXIfr

26/12/2024

The holiday season can be tough, but it is important to remember you are not alone.

Need someone to talk to? The following support lines are available 24/7:

Lifeline
Speak to a trained Crisis Supporter either over the phone, via text or online at any time of the day or night.
📞 Call - 13 11 14
📱 Text – 0477 13 11 14
💻 Chat online - https://www.lifeline.org.au/crisis-chat/

Beyond Blue
If you’re going through a hard time right now, the Beyond Blue Support Service is available 24/7 for brief counselling.
📞 Call - 1300 22 4636
💻 Chat online - https://www.beyondblue.org.au/get-support/talk-to-a-counsellor/chat

13Yarn
If you, or someone you know, are feeling worried or no good, talk with an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Crisis Supporter.
📞 Call - 13 92 76, available 24/7

1800RESPECT
Available for free, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week to support people impacted by domestic, family or sexual violence.
📞 Call - 1800 737 732
📱 Text - 0458 737 732
💻 Chat online - https://1800respect.org.au/

Kids Helpline
Australia’s only free (even from a mobile), confidential 24/7 online and phone counselling service for young people aged 5 to 25.
📞 Call - 1800 55 1800
💻 Online chat - https://kidshelpline.com.au/get-help/webchat-counselling/

1300 MH CALL
A confidential mental health telephone triage service that will link you to your nearest Queensland Public Mental Health service.
📞 Call - 1300 642 255

If it’s an emergency, call 000.⁠

Check out the Find Help page on our website for more support services ⬇️
https://www.qldmentalhealthweek.org.au/find-help/

Links to helpful websites and resources, covering 24/7 helplines, gambling assistance, relationships, eating disorders, parenting, and more.

23/12/2024

Weather you have been naughty or nice

Merry X-mas to all of my dear friends all over the world ❤

Merry Christmas 🎄 Merry Christmas 🎄 Selamat Hari Natal 🎄 God Jul 🎄 Joyeux Noël 🎄 Merry Nollag 🎄 Buon Natale 🎄 ¡Feliz Navidad 🎄 Merry Christmas i 🎄 Boldog Karácsonyt 🎄 Häid jõule 🎄 🎄 🎄 Gelukkigоства 🎄 Hyvääелукту Krismasви 🎄t 🎄 Noel kutul olsun 🎄 Hä вестви 🎄т 🎄 jujuč 🎄 คริสต์มาสー สุขสันต์วัน 🎄 Merry Christmas 🎄

22/12/2024

Take notice City of Moreton Bay
https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1EvviX9ZgF/?mibextid=wwXIfr

21/12/2024

City of Moreton Bay DON’T do it
Rangers you can choose not to participate and refuse.
When you try to take a homeless man’s greatest love and only companion his dog you will be putting your rangers in danger.

The homeless have lost everything, has nothing left and has nothing to loose. They will starve to ensure their dog eats and MBRC are going to send rangers in to confiscate the dog?

17/12/2024

Big cheers to the thousands of professional dog trainers training peoples pets to build a closer relationship and fixing dog behavior problems EVERY SINGLE DAY.

Whilst the FORCE FREE INFLUENCERS are still talking about their false ideology and trying to ban life saving tools killing off 1000’s of pets. F**K YOU

17/12/2024

When your on the bones of your arse and the council want to confiscate your pet dog. The very last thing your clinging too.
All the rangers that were experienced dog people are all gone replaced with rangers specialising in compliance and not much dog experience.
This is a disgrace

Check out what Morton Bay Council is enforcing on the Homeless. This is absolutely ridiculous. What are your thoughts?