
23/06/2025
Why do horses say No?
There’s a large part of traditional training I used to follow which is all about getting the horse to say ‘yes’ to everything we ask. Without question, hesitation or ‘disrespect’. But is it really an ask if the only available answer is a ‘yes’?
Or is it a command?
People have made comments to me before about how ‘obedient’ my horse appears to be. Which is ironic given that all my horses have the same degree of choice in training. I rarely ever command my horses to do anything. And here’s why:
There’s only three basic reasons horses will refuse to do what we ask.
1. They physically can’t do what we are asking
2. They do not understand what we are asking
3. They do not want to do what we are asking
Let’s put that into human perspective:
If I asked you to do a backflip right now - chances are you probably wouldn’t be physically fit or capable of doing one.
If I asked you a question in a foreign language would you be able to answer correctly right away?
What if I asked to borrow your car? Phone or even your shoes? It’s pretty likely you wouldn’t want a relative stranger to drive your car, mess with your phone or take your shoes.
The idea that increasing pressure or even adding punishment for not immediately complying or trying is a remanent of authoritarian ideology.
I don’t really want a horse that is complying out of blind obedience, fear and stress. I want a horse that is ready to listen, learn and choose to participate with me.