24/07/2024
As a welfare advocate, I have been observing the developments of the Charlotte DuJardin abuse allegations over the past 24 hours. What we see happening here is cognitive dissonance in real time.
A few important details for those who may not have been following the story so far:
- Charlotte DuJardin is a decorated Olympian from Great Britain, fully expected to be a contender for the podium in Dressage this go-round
- She is also a fairly new mother, who has dealt with depression in the past
- She and her mentor Carl Hester often show publicly their horses in ample turnout with friends, something that few high end show horses are allowed to enjoy
- Charlotte released a statement before any of the press regarding this ban where she referred to her actions as "a lapse in judgement" and "out of character" and claimed the incident in question happened 4 years ago, but said she herself made the decision to withdraw from the Olympics
- The FEI is launching an investigation, and has issued a provisional competition ban of 6 months
- The video is a lesson where Charlotte is teaching and whipping the rider's horse from the ground 24 times in a 1 minute period
- According to the rider's lawyer, the video took place in 2022 not 4 years ago.
- The rider is now 19, so would have been 17 at the time.
- According to the rider's lawyer, the rider was gifted a lesson with Charlotte from a sponsor, and was lead to believe that these practices were normal at elite levels of training.
So, on one hand, we see a well respected, successful trainer who has made a lapse in judgement. As fellow trainers, the urge to give grace, to wait for details is strong. We have all made mistakes in moments of frustration, or used too much force, or done things out of ignorance that in hindsight might make us cringe.
But then we consider the timeline - two years, not four years as Charlotte said. So then, is this not an isolated incident? And, if one has a lapse in judgement, how long does that lapse proceed...in the video she whips the horse 24 times. Charlotte can be heard to say, "Get going, old man!" and "This is so sh*t" and, although it's hard to make out, when the rider seems upset and seems to question what is happening Charlotte replies, "These are just taps, he doesn't respect the whip" Which the audio in the video will tell you is gaslighting at best.
Deep inside all of us, is a young girl with dreams, like the rider in the video, who was likely ecstatic to be able to take a lesson with one of her idols. I think, at the end of the day, we have to reconnect with that side of us, and use it as a litmus test. Would the little girl that ran to hug her pony approve of this? Would this bring her joy or horror? Charlotte too has this little girl inside her, and a daughter of her own, and I suspect as the cognitive dissonance wears off, she may really grasp the opportunity here to make a change, and restore her good name as an exemplary competition rider.
I am glad too, that the FEI has moved to act swiftly. However, I do notice that no actions have been taken against Werth, Fry or Kittel, all of whom have competed horses with blue tongues in the run-up to the Olympics. It seems they only act when absolutely no other option is afforded to them.
Given that this video was released by a very young rider, and not, as I initially suspected by a competing business interest of Charlotte, I commend her bravery. The backlash against whistleblowers and the disempowered in the horse world can be severe, particularly when it comes to well loved, big name riders.
Finally, for those who are shocked, I would urge you to consider that despite what we wish to believe, in elite sport these practices are the norm, not the exception. Is it everyone? Certainly not. But is it much more widespread than we are lead to believe? Absolutely. We can't rely on the FEI to self police. Like the young rider in the video, we have to make the change ourselves. If we want to save Dressage as a sport, and an art, we have to be the examples we wish to see, and keep pressure on for the FEI to adhere to their own rules.
It's a sad day for Charlotte, and for the sport of dressage, but maybe, just maybe, a small light at the end of the tunnel for advocates who want to see the FEI actually enforce its own rules. I wouldn't say I'm hopeful, but I would say, it's a start.
For those who are curious, here is the video of the incident in question, with sound:
Charlotte Dujardin, Britain’s three-time Olympic equestrian champion, has been shown repeatedly striking a horse on the back of the legs with a whip in distr...