22/07/2024
Uncovering the truth: crediting sources and the complexity of originality.
It's important to acknowledge the originators of ideas, but sometimes the picture is more nuanced than we think. Our perceptions can be deceiving, and the true story behind a concept or method may be nuanced or multifaceted. It's not always straightforward.
In my own course, I meticulously cite multiple sources throughout its entirety, yet I recently received two contrasting messages from students, ironically on the same morning.
One student misinterpreted the exercises as a rehashing of an unrelated method, which left me perplexed. Meanwhile, another student expressed gratitude, recognizing that the exercises address the very issues caused by that same method.
The latter student was correct, as my exercises are rooted in my experience at a biomechanics rehabilitation facility, where I learned techniques to resolve those exact issues, backed by information gleaned in Classical texts as well as modern movement science.
It's intriguing how perception can vary so greatly, and how people become fixated on issues of credit. Even when sources are clearly cited, some individuals still claim theft or plagiarism. I wonder if this isn't a ploy to garner sympathy and followers by feigning vulnerability. In my opinion, true understanding (consilience) isn't about tearing others down.
The more I delve into Classical texts, the more I realize that nothing in horse training is truly novel. Humans have worked with horses for millennia; it's arrogant to assume we've invented something entirely new.
The irony of human nature is that we often neglect to learn from the past, despite being surrounded by the wisdom of previous generations readily available to us. Rather than rediscover concepts in dusty old texts, many are intent to try and reinvent the wheel. And when similarities arise, we can be quick to cry foul, without considering the nuances that set them apart. It's a curious paradox - our ability to innovate and progress, paired with a tendency to repeat the mistakes of history.
Horses have taught me that true humility comes from embracing the complexity of knowledge, acknowledging the contributions of others, and recognizing that wisdom is a continuous thread that weaves through time, connecting us all. 💕