05/08/2022
A shelter employee asked me: “How do you see your privilege as it relates to animal welfare?”
When I asked for clarification, she said, “You are a white male who has had access to a higher education.”
She took particular offense at my article criticizing Kristen Hassen of Austin Pets Alive for telling people that shelters faced only one of two choices: killing animals or abandoning them on the street. I argued that such a view was defeatist, contradicted by the evidence, and deadly to animals. Instead, I asked people to embrace a third choice: No Kill.
She also did not like my tone, which is not uncommon among staff at shelters that kill animals. When they encounter people who refuse to couch violence against animals in softer terms, refuse to engage in their carefully crafted double-speak, or counter their excuse-making with viable solutions and alternatives, they often mistakenly conflate honesty and optimism with rudeness and arrogance.
Frequently, they then accuse those calling for lifesaving alternatives of being bullies, when their own actions toward sheltered animals are the very definition of the term: “a person who habitually seeks to harm… those whom they perceive as vulnerable.” This is why my response to the question of how I see my “privilege as it relates to animal welfare” is that I don’t. And I don’t because animals care about staying alive. They do not care about the skin color or s*x of those trying to stop people from killing them. But I also don’t because her question has it backward: she and her colleagues are the ones who possess it — and do so to the extreme.
If they choose to, they can poison or gas animals, place them in an incinerator, and turn their bodies into ash without any repercussions. Responding to criticism of this deadly power imbalance with the question she poses shows just how deep this sense of privilege is: to those who possess it, it is so invisible as to be construed as the natural order. To even question it is heretical. Hence, the deflection.
My new Substack article, “The Power and ‘Privilege’ to Kill,” is here: https://bit.ly/3bxQ8wd.
If you are not a subscriber, sign up while there to receive an email whenever a new article or podcast is published.