25/01/2025
One of the most common defenses for outdated dog training methods is “nuance”.
After all, if every dog is different, shouldn’t we consider all types of training methods, from treats and play to punishment with prong or shock collars?
Let’s talk about why this common talking point among some “dog trainers” is nothing more than a cop-out for a lack of knowledge on what to do next.
Nuance in dog training is about truly understanding the dog in front of you and making thoughtful, compassionate choices that help them succeed.
For years, many of us were taught methods that focused on controlling behaviors by suppressing them, often with tools like prong collars or harsh corrections.
While those techniques may seem effective in the short term, decades of research and experience have shown that they never address the underlying reasons for a dog’s behavior.
Instead, these “old school” methods can lead to stress, confusion, and sometimes even harm the bond between a dog and their guardian. And this is no way to serve the public as a professional.
Modern training takes a different approach.
It’s about noticing the small details, the flicker of an ear, the tension in a dog’s body, or the difference between curiosity and stress. It’s about stepping back, understanding what the dog is experiencing, and finding a way forward that builds trust and confidence, not fear.
For example, when a dog pulls on the leash, instead of relying on quick, harsh corrections to stop the behavior, we can focus on initially setting the dog up for success by managing the environment, lowering their stress, and teaching them new skills in a way they can truly understand. We can work all the way up to the challenging scenario without the need for punishment at all.
If you’re a professional trainer, you may have been taught more traditional methods in the past. It’s something many of us can relate to.
But as we learn more about how dogs think, feel, and learn, we have the opportunity to grow and evolve. That’s something every educator should be proud to do.
A “crossover trainer” is someone who’s made that leap, moving away from older techniques toward a more modern, humane approach. Their stories are a powerful reminder that change is possible.
If you’re a crossover trainer, we’d love to hear from you. What inspired your shift? What has your journey been like?
And for anyone who’s exploring new ideas, feel free to share your thoughts or ask questions.
This is a space for learning and growing together. We’re so glad to have you as part of the Dog Training Revolution!
