08/15/2026
Punishing unwanted behaviour requires the behaviour to occur in the first place.
Training to address the cause of WHY a behaviour exists involves meeting needs, achieving emotional regulation and does not seek to provoke a bad reaction or cause a horse to “practice” an unwanted behaviour in order to correct it.
The idea that trainers who don’t promote punishment as a primary means of addressing an unwanted behaviour are “unsafe” and create “dangerous behaviour in horses” is laughable because the primary goal of ethical horse training is to avoid the occurrence of dangerous behaviour in the first place.
It doesn’t get as much applause or anywhere near as many views but any time I am given a dangerous horse to work with, my primary goal is to make them look as safe as possible because if I provoke dangerous behaviour in training, it means that something has been overlooked or wasn’t addressed for whatever reason.
We don’t need to create dangerous behaviour first to fix it.
Punishment relies on addressing problem behaviours as they occur.
Systematic behavioural modification relies on addressing what causes the behaviour in the first place and taking away the horse’s need to use that behaviour as a coping mechanism.
All behaviour has an underlying motivation.
Punishment suppresses the behaviour without actually addressing the cause.
It’s kind of like putting a bandaid on a wound that needs sutures.
Ethical horse training treats the “wound” for infection and sutures it instead of just covering it up and hiding it from view.