Can you reward aggression/reactivity with treats? Probably not.
This can get pretty technical so I’ve tried to put it in simple terms, but let me know if you want a more technical explanation!
When considering if a behavior will be reinforced we need to know - the function/reason, whats already reinforcing it, if its involuntary or voluntary, the emotion driving it, if its instinctual, & how motivating the reinforcers are.
Dog training ideologies fall on a spectrum, with one extreme side focussing ‘too much’ on theory, even if application of the theory doesn’t work as well as they suggest. While the other end don’t bother to learn any credible theory & push that apprehensive dogs being trained only with force, who comply with commands, reflect ‘success’. Like almost anything, truth cannot be found in the extremes, even though snippets come from both sides. But, the greater truth usually culminates somewhere in the middle.
We’ve been away from training due to injuries, but still integrating short/sweet sessions to keep progressing.This session working on: not going past dumbell on retrieve, front sit position & dumbell hold ❤️
She lets him think he’s tougher than he is 😂🖤
Last run before heading off to Melbourne for the workshop! ❤️
Reward delivery is a skill that can make a big difference when training reactivity or for mouthy dogs. 🐾Trying to get dogs to be ‘gentle’ can reduce their drive and energy when rewarding, so instead, allow them to be enthusiastic and deliver rewards with more control and save your fingers from teeth at the same time!
Halo ‘is’ a beauty queen 🥰
ALL these dogs have tools on. ALL these programs are focussing on emotional stabilty. Imagine if the only difference between a force free trainer & a GOOD ‘non’ force free trainer, is that we have other options to ‘add’. Those options could equate to seconds
When 99% of your dog’s recall is fun, for the 1% times you NEED IT, it will be a reflex ❤️
Confirmation Bias in Dog Training
I had a phone conversation with a very high profile & highly published scientist recently.
I asked why they thought position statements like AVSAB state:
“theres no evidence aversive methods are more effective than reward based methods in any context”
while omitting studies that do show efficacy where reward based does not in their ref lists.. they answered.. “Which studies are you talking about”.
When I named 4 or 5… they replied that THEY HAD NOT HEARD OF THEM.
Think about that. PhD’s writing scientific papers on the subjects of training methods, advising on efficacy, welfare & future directions of research, who state ‘there is no evidence’, AREN’T AWARE OF THE EVIDENCE.
The confirmation bias runs through welfare, training & behavioural science orgs at such a level, that scientific evidence that doesn’t fit the story is erased.
Snake Avoidance Dog Training
If a positive reinforcement approach was SHOWN to be effective in numerous dogs, I would sing it from the roof tops. Unfortunately in this case, its wishful thinking that is unlikly to work