16/10/2025
đ Why Bark Collars Are Cruel â and Why They Should Be Banned
Bark collars are often seen as a âquick fixâ to a barking problem â but the truth is, theyâre nothing more than a band-aid that covers up the real issue.
If your dog is barking excessively, thereâs always a reason behind it â stress, insecurity, frustration, lack of boundaries, or confusion about leadership. When you put a bark collar on your dog, you might silence the sound, but youâre not addressing the cause.
What actually happens is your dog still wants to bark â because mentally and emotionally, nothing has changed. Youâve only suppressed the behaviour, not resolved it. That suppression creates more stress, confusion, and anxiety, because your dog is being punished for expressing the very emotions that you, through your current structure and relationship, have helped shape.
In most cases, youâll start to see deferred behaviours appear. Because the dog can no longer bark, the stress and frustration have to go somewhere â so it may start to escape, dig, destroy, pace, or become neurotic. Physically, you may even see your dogâs body respond with skin rashes, ear infections, hot spots, or other health issues. There is always going to be a consequence when we suppress a problem instead of resolving it.
True behaviour change doesnât come from pain, fear, or suppression. It comes from clear leadership, consistent rules, and healthy boundaries that help your dog feel safe, understood, and calm.
Bark collars donât teach calm â they teach fear.
And thatâs why theyâre cruel.