24/07/2024
Tässä taas ajattelemisen aihetta sadeiltaan. Toivottavasti kaikki ainakin pyrkisivät eettiseen suuntaan, eikä esimerkiksi kilpailu mene eettisyyden edelle. Tutkimustietoa tulee kuitenkin jatkuvasti lisää ja antaa myös mahdollisuuden parantaa omaa toimintaa. Täällä uurastetaan edelleen oman talliprojektin parissa ja kunhan tulee valmista, voisin ehkä järjestää jonkin happeningin. :)
Is riding ethical?
I find myself grappling with this question yet again, particularly in light of the troubling footage that surfaced of Charlotte Dujardin, causing her withdrawal from the Paris 2024 Olympic Games.
This incident comes right after a scandal in late 2023 involving Helgstrand Dressage, where undercover, heartbreaking footage showed the terrifying training conditions at their facility. It goes without saying that the evidence of Charlotte Dujardin or Helgstrand Dressage are NOT examples of ethical treatment, but it begs us to ponder where the line between ethical and unethical truly lies and why individuals, often celebrated and accomplished in their fields, transgress it time and time again? So I ask the question...
Is riding ethical?
It’s a complex and deeply personal one. Here is what I think…
Ethics, as a concept, revolves around principles of right and wrong behaviour, particularly concerning moral duties and obligations.
However, the challenge arises from the diversity of opinions within the equestrian community. Practices that one person deems ethical—such as using certain training methods or equipment—might be viewed as controversial or unacceptable by others. This variability in perspectives underscores the importance of critical reflection and informed decision-making in equine care and training.
For many equestrians, riding represents a profound bond with horses—a partnership built on trust, communication, and mutual respect. It's a relationship that brings joy, fulfillment, and physical activity to both horse and rider. Riding can provide horses with mental stimulation, regular exercise, and purpose, contributing positively to their well-being, when approached responsibly - again, it depends on what your definition of “responsibly” is.
We believe in advocating for horses’ well-being above all else. We believe in seeing horses not just as companions or tools but as sentient beings deserving of respect and compassionate care. This perspective informs our approach to riding and training—placing emphasis on understanding the horse's emotions, needs, and preferences.
Is riding ethical? Yes and no… What do you think?
As we approach the Paris 2024 Olympic Games, my hope is that we witness shining examples of true horsemanship in equestrian competitions—where partnerships with horses are built on trust and compassion. hope that we don't see tight flashes or nosebands, horses behind the vertical, blue tongues or harsh equipment.
And if these practices do surface and sadly I’m sure that they will, I hope the governing body responsible for upholding welfare at these events (yes, FEI, I'm looking at you!) acts relentlessly against it, with integrity and accountability.
With each scandal that arises, I hope it sparks more conversation and action toward improving equine welfare in equestrian sports, urging us all to become better humans for our horses.