06/04/2021
The Hockey Stick Effect... and horse training/rehabilitation
It's such a common phenomenon for owners and trainers to push for the end results before actually doing the work that creates the results. The biggest thing... gadgets... training aids... and lots of quick fix type methods. The use of "stuff" allows us to feel like we are getting the big picture in a shorter amount of time because of the "look" the gadgets create. But are we really getting real results?
The Hockey Stick Effect is not for the impatient because it is slow to start, stagnant during growth but quick to come together once you put the time and effort into the boring and seemingly pointless work. This is where there is a gadget for every problem a horse could give us. Have a problem? This piece of tack will stop your horse from doing X...
A horse carries his head to high? There's a tool out there to make the head be lower.
A horse rushes under saddle? There's a bit that keeps him from running off.
A horse that is lazy? There's a rowel you can add to your spur that will surely liven him up.
Most people use gadgets because they don't have time or knowledge to work and wait for the real fix. Gadgets are empowering because they ALMOST work. And once that gadget quits working, there is another gadget that follows behind it. Take bits for example... you can start in a nice smooth snaffle with the option of escalating to barbaric, sharp and heavy leveraged bits depending on the problems your horse gives you.
Basically, for every side effect a medication causes, there is another medication you can take to ease those side effects. Pretty soon you have a whole medicine cabinet of stuff you have to take in order to maybe feel ok. Instead... get rid of the fake and manufactured fixes and get back to basics if you really want to quit pulling your hair out.
Basics are not ever a quick fix but they are the long term fix. It's takes time to develop a new and healthy normal. For the most part, we don't actually know what normal is for horses. From behavior, to hoof health, to diet, social manners, etc. we are so conditioned to abnormal health that we even know what a healthy normal is for our horses.
If you relate training progress to the graphs, you don't see much, if any progress for a while when you first start the education process. You may see a 1% improvement per session if you're lucky. Most would judge that as being unproductive training. But after you accomplish say 100 days of slow, methodical work in a certain area, you have quite the result to show off. This is where a 30, 60 or 90 day c**t start/tune up/foundation program absolutely drives me crazy with anxiety! No matter how hard I try, to get a real result that is going to last, you have to have the time it takes to follow the graph and every horse is going to have their own timeline.
As an example, I had a mare that I did a pretty strict training regiment on as a way to hopefully fix a problem I didn't know how to fix. For essentially 100 days, we did slow, methodical and very boring work. Basically, it was the 1%/day goal of getting something productive done. I didn't realize this at the time but it literally took that amount of time (100 days) to reach that uphill slop of the hockey stick where "all of the sudden" my problems were gone. When I went back and tried what used to be my problem area again, the problem I once had was nearly gone and I hadn't actually addressed my problem head on. My problem was caused by a lack of basics my horse needed in order to do the job I wanted to do. She was the poster child for needing the gadgets the keep the head down, and the bit to keep her from rushing off and the spurs to make her get off my leg, but once the holes were beginning to be filled, those gadgets were no longer needed. I did a few simple tasks that changed the health and well being of my horse and I didn't need to force her to do it.
The last thing I'll say about gadgets is the the negative effects they have. Not just physically, but mentally. Physically, when you use the stuff to put a horse in a box, to create the look and shape you want, the horse often has to contort himself in order to go to that shape. Often times we end up helping the horse strengthen the wrong muscles because they physically can't do the outline we want. On a deeper level though, it's the mental side of gadgets. When you put a horse in a box, where he's held together with restraints and pressures, you lose connection with the horse. The horse no longer has a choice nor does he feel inclined to choose better options. Essentially, once you say "do this and do that" the horse becomes robot and not a partner.
When we remove the quick fix "stuff", go back to basics and allow the horse to learn the material, you have training installed for life. Why? Because the horse is choosing how to behave. The horse chooses what feels good and what doesn't. The horse remembers what feels good and he'll choose to do what feels good to him. So in the beginning, it's slow because it takes time to create a new, healthy normals, but long term, good, solid training where a horse learns to do it himself without feeling forced into it, is the lifetime fix.