12/03/2024
*** LENGTH OF SCHOOLING SESSIONS and TIRED HORSES ***
Following on from a recent post of mine in which I shared the fact that I worked Mabel hard when she started leaping and rodeoing, I thought I’d give my opinion on how long horses should be worked for.
Some people got very upset that I stated that I worked Mabel until she was “exhausted”. I use the term, “exhausted”, a lot. I say on a daily basis that I am exhausted; this does not mean that I am collapsing and need to go on intravenous fluids and be in a hospital bed. All of my horses look exhausted every evening; only 4 of the 7 in my barn are ridden, so it is a term I use loosely, as do many, many people. When I state that one of my horses is exhausted, it means they are mentally and physically tired, not that they are dropping onto their knees. Mabel was completely exhausted last night after her 15-20 minute walk hack earlier that day. This isn’t cruel, or an animal welfare issue. After Mabel’s rodeo session the other week, I rode her forward in trot and canter for less than 15 minutes. She wasn’t even sweating, and she isn’t clipped. In my opinion, she felt exhausted at that point. I probably could have cantered her around for a further 15 minutes quite easily, but I normally stop whilst my horses’ brains and bodies are still fresh. Just to clear up any concerns! I am completely transparent and honest about what I do and how I train my horses, to the point that I would happily be live streamed on a daily basis (I may need the odd swear word editing out to keep it PC 🙈). I’m not going to hide the fact that I occasionally use a training aid on one horse, which is absolutely not a welfare issue. I’m also not going to hide the fact that I quietly and correctly use spurs; again, absolutely not a welfare issue. I think it’s actually extremely important that we educate both the general public and inexperienced horse owners on the fact that training aids used by experienced riders are often much less of a welfare issue than they may either look/appear, or than a less experienced rider yanking on a horse’s mouth in a snaffle.
Onto the post! The following is my opinion. It is based on both my experience and understanding as a rider and horsewoman, and my knowledge as an equine vet with 15 years’ experience.
My horses are never, ever, schooled for longer than 30 minutes. This is more than enough time to achieve something, and if you haven’t achieved your goal after 30 minutes, it’s unlikely that you will by plugging on for longer. This 30 minutes includes my warm up, and a couple of short walk breaks.
I haven’t really had lessons for many years, but when I trained with Jennie Loriston-Clarke, the lesson time was 40 minutes. This includes warming up and warming down. Frequently, they wouldn’t go on past 30 minutes. Horses learn by repetition, not by grilling them for an hour at a time.
Horses also break easily. They damage ligaments and tendons. Yes, this is often unlucky and frequently caused by a sudden twist in the field. But it’s also frequently caused by too much schooling, especially if the surface is deep, or uneven. Proximal suspensory ligaments are not designed to take the weight of a horse in collected work for hours. Once a PSL is damaged, you are often looking at a lengthy rehab, or surgery to cut the nerve that supplies it (neurectomy). That is not to say that every horse with PSD has been overworked, before I offend anyone!
Horses break more easily when they are tired. A tired horse is more likely to trip, possibly resulting in ligament or tendon damage. Muscle needs some degree of fatigue to condition it, but not to the point of complete exhaustion.
A horse’s brain also breaks easily. Fatigue can also be mental. Granted, some horses’ brains don’t take much to break, but if a horse becomes stressed or can’t work out what you are asking him that day, then take a 24 hour break, and go for a hack, or just lunge the next day. Or give him a day off.
Most horses will be fit enough for their job, without being ridden 6 days a week. The main issue with lower level competition horses, is that many are fat. I’m aware that this term will offend lots, but it’s a fact. Exercise is a great way to get horses to lose weight, true, but not without reducing the amount of grass or hard feed they are receiving. Schooling a fat horse for an hour, will cause joint, tendon, and ligament problems in the long term. Find hills to slowly jog them up, or even walk them up, if you are wanting to exercise more to help with fitness and/or weight loss. Don’t school them more. Trotting endlessly around a flat arena isn’t really going to help with fitness.
If you are going to school, then add plenty of variety. Make sure the horse is working from behind, and not dragging himself along on his forehand. If you don’t enjoy schooling, you will be more inclined to switch off and trot endless 20m circles. So go for a hack first, and then just do ten minutes of intense schooling when you get home. That will keep both human and horse brains fresh!
This is an enormous topic, and it would take me days to cover it all, so this is really a brief summary. Keep schooling sessions short and productive, and if the session is going wrong, take a break!
Photo is of my wonderful Harold, back in his Eventing days!