29/06/2025
SECTION 3 DDA CASE v POLICE SCOTLAND
This court case was an aggrevated section 3 case that occurred back in April 2021, this beautiful girl was facing destruction by the courts, which I was instructed on and thankfully we won against Police Scotland in June 2024- no destruction order and she had no restrictions put on her either.
I’ve been meaning to post to highlight how not only chaotic and complex it was but how the humans involved can get it so very wrong! It was a case that was thought to be difficult to win but we did 🙂
The media/newspapers at the time with their headlines such as “POLICE OFFICERS SAVAGED BY DOGS FOR TRYING TO BREAKUP LOCKDOWN PARTY” which couldn’t be anymore wrong, do no favours in causing hysteria to the public and putting certain breeds in a bad light! Not only were the media putting out the wrong info during the case but also after, stating my assessment carried out at the dogs home, her public tests, along with the owners home report, and my court report was all carried out by the Aberdeen dog warden, which again, couldn’t be further from the truth.
The dog world in regards to the police, the courts, the wardens and the media is a lost internal communication system! It is such a saddening system, that can get it all so very wrong for our dogs and it really needs to be stepped up and cleaned up! We all have a responsibility when working with the dogs caught up in the justice system, we could be working together to create a well functioning system for good!! We have a huge human made mess! The dogs are the easy part.
Now to the case……
This beautiful girl is Bella and she had just moved into her new home a week prior to the incident. Which is unsettling for any dog emotionally, mentally, and biologically. It’s a lot for their body to handle and they don’t get a chance to totally relax daily, even after sleep. It can keep them in a state of arousal taking longer to decompress. Which means it’s easier for them to trigger stack to all the environmental pressures, and that can cause a hyper vigilant state of alertness.
Pair this with Bella having just had major surgery in the February 2021 for mastitis and having necrotic tissue removal, removal of internal masses and part of her uterus removed, she was left with a very large scar down her torso, with only three ni***es remaining. So she was still recovering hormonally and physically. We know that pain and health are a major contributing factor to behaviour and must always be considered for how dogs can react.
On the evening of the incident, during lockdown restrictions, Bella’s owners who have a large family, after helping each other that day moving some things ended up with a house full of around 8+ family members. Police attended asking them to leave the premises, of which the owners asked for some time to clear out and make arrangements, for taxis to be called etc.
Police, unbeknown to the owners, made arrangements for additional police units to meet in a nearby lane surrounding the property, making the decision for multiple police officers to enter the property from the front and rear door. The situation then becoming chaotic and volatile.
No planning made for the multiple dogs they were aware of inside the property, no dog unit called, no thoughts made for how this would affect the dogs when dozens of police officers piled into the home with dogs running freely inside and the chaos this would cause. No thought for public safety, if dogs spill out into the street from these decisions that were made by the police, yet owners would be punished for the very thing!
When police officers scaled the rear garden fence heading to the back kitchen door, very aware of the multiple dogs in the kitchen, Bella ran out of the door barking close to their legs. The police officers labeled her aggressive for this and retreated back to the fence, but still decided to enter the home when Bella went back inside. The police officers passing the other dogs and people in the kitchen area, continuing through to the front of the home where a disturbance was happening from the other officers entering the front of the property.
Which was Bella’s owner, who was now in an altercation in a narrow confined hallway at the front of the home, with lots of officers, other family members and lots of shouting and physical chaos. Bella’s owner was being held against the wall by officers and handcuffed but at the same time being told to get his dog under control. Bella was described as barking and agitated by Police Scotland officers and although her owner wasn’t allowed to move, he was told if he didn’t get her under control she would be fu£&ing sprayed!
A police officer used their foot to “usher” (their words), although we could also say pushed Bella back into the living room area, whilst instructing the owner to get her under control. Where they seen someone grab hold of her collar and they believed she wouldn’t be free again.
However, just a moment later Bella was heard barking and the officer saw her run into the hallway and lunging and biting an officer on the leg. The same officer who done so before “ushered” her back again with their foot into the living room and gave clear instructions to get the dog under control.
But the chaos continued for Bella when her owner was pushed during a struggle by one of the officers out of the hallway and out the front door, resulting in three police officers and Bella’s owner falling down some quite steep concrete steps and onto the narrow gravel path. One of the officers who fell onto Bella’s owner felt a sharp pain in their leg before seeing Bella run away onto the grass in front of them. Bella had fell amongst them all. Again the officer shouting for someone to get the dog under control as they describe her as agitated while there was a struggle going on on the ground, and legs were being kicked in amongst all of this.
The altercation of falling out of the doorway would cause a startled fear response for Bella, and it is at this point everything in the situation becomes over stimulating, the combined continued threats of sudden unexpected, scary strangers in her home, the sights, sounds, smells, with the unpredictability, she has escalated from behaviours of barking, frantically running around, nothing is working, to nipping and the main point is making the scary concerning threat go away out of her safe space. She is now caught up in the altercation in the confined hallway.
To then being described as running around barking, agitated, giving one bite, and then pushed away, shows she had no real intent of doing damage and she was also startled when as already mentioned the multiple scary unpredictable strangers appeared from nowhere entering her home, which is her place of safety. There is no sustained attacks. There is no savage attacks!
Fortunately for Bella she does have good bite inhibition, using her barking behaviour, and nipping as no more than a reaction and warning. There was no true intention of harm. Most healthy domestic dogs exercise bite inhibition if put in a situation to bite. Most dog bites are escalated warnings without intent to injure. The intent is to create distance between the dog and what they perceive as a threat.
Bella reacted through a root of fear, anxiety, stress and being startled, a dog dealing with a sudden high state of stress with her home invaded, a place of safety, and combined chaos from all the humans involved in the incident. Her physical pain and health also a large contributing factor. Pain causes a low tolerance threshold and changes in behaviour. An easy-going dog being faced with the threat of being touched, or startled with someone in their flight path will likely show reactive displays. When these communication signal attempts are ignored, such as barking, lunging or running forward, the dog’s signals will escalate up the ladder to using their teeth as they only have their mouth to defend themselves.
I repeat this so much, but every experience a dog is exposed to shapes and moulds their behaviour. They rely on us for everything, learning from us and the environment we create around them and put them in. Behaviour is fluid and they react to everything in their environment, and it is up to us to teach them and give them the correct guidance.
Bella had a great temperament on her assessment. She was an affectionate and friendly girl despite having two strangers present on that day. She has a good bond with both owners and her family, and she is a well-balanced dog living in a multi-dog household.
It is very clear the incident was chaotic. Her owner admitted his demeanour and disturbance had contributed to Bella behaving the way she had on the evening of the incident
However, for me all the humans involved on the evening of the incident are responsible. Everyone contributed to how this beautiful girl reacted. From the multiple humans asked inside to get the dog under control while her owner was physically restrained and unable to take control of Bella. The whole incident was chaotic.
We have humans behaving in a chaotic manner who have logic and reason and yet the dogs who are guided by humans and rely on us for everything in their daily needs and environment are not allowed to react amongst the chaos that is caused by those very humans?! They are just to be destroyed?!
Our aim can only be to equip our dogs with the skills to allow them to adjust and behave in an acceptable way in our society. Resulting in a dog that is better able to cope with new experiences, and unpredictable or fearful situations.
So therefore, we as the humans must take a common-sense approach to human judgement and error.
It’s pretty evident that Bella did not carry out “savage” attacks, and it’s pretty evident that Bella did not carry out “sustained” attacks!
Police Scotland must look at how their own behaviour affects the outcome in situations in regards to our dogs. To de-escalate not escalate. This is not the only occasion. To seek destruction on a dog in which their own behaviour is a huge factor in the cause is ludicrous. Things must change.
A huge thanks to Debbie at Just Defence Law on this case. Great firm to work with. And a huge thanks for the person assisting me at assessment.
Alexis 🐶