
22/03/2025
So insightful. Let’s all see how similar we are to our beloved animals 💗
Why Anthropomorphising Matters.
I still hear so many horse trainers describing the danger of anthropomorphic thinking in relation to horses. And I understand why - it’s a back lash against all the years of us attributing horses with the capacity to ‘get one over on us’ ‘take the p*ss’ - all that stuff.
However, it is pretty widely recognised now that we’re more similar than we are dissimilar. We share more emotions than we don’t with many other animals. And maybe if we really dared to anthropomorphize that might significantly change how we treat animals - which is probably why we don’t do it.
For instance, I have just ‘bought’ a new horse. Even at that level of possession and ownership of another being I find myself baulking, but it’s the truth.
I believe he has many of the same emotions and needs as I have. Fear, jealousy, curiosity, contentment. The need for safety, the need for comfort, the need to move and to rest.
Last year I went on holiday by mistake, I was going to visit a friend in Spain and en route I spent a few days at what turned out to be a very busy seaside resort on the Med. I have travelled solo a lot in my life but I’ve never really ‘holidayed’. When I realised the numbers of people were much greater than I had experienced in many years , and I was ‘stuck’ here for several days I went into full blown panic. My senses were in absolute overdrive and my choices were taken away. Now, I got over myself, worked things out and had an excellent time - reminding myself that this was actually all my own choice.
The horse I have just arranged to be transported from Portugal had no such choice. He didn’t know why he was leaving his familiar and safe surroundings. He had no sense of why he was in this huge metal box full of other horses. He knew no one, understood nothing about the present or the future. He could not call his friend to be talked down and reminded that everything would be OK.
Ethologists are changing the nature of how we study and understand the more-than-human animal kingdom and are even daring to use words such as ‘love’. Maybe if humans can experience love for each other, then the complex animal communities they observe can also contain love. Maybe?
Possibly the reason your horse is ‘trying to get out of work’ is because the work feels bad. In just the same way you want to go home early if your job is boring or stressful. Maybe the reason your horse is being ‘difficult’ about having their feet picked up is because they’re confused or someone taught them badly - just like you might be ‘difficult’ about doing your accounts.
The new horse who has landed here on Dartmoor is actually doing brilliantly, but the first day he arrived he was really frightened and I felt it in my stomach. Just imagine if you were him….
I’ve taken things really slowly with him, only changing one thing at a time and keeping his world pretty small. He seems to appreciate that and is enjoying some things which are new in his life, like the view and endless armfuls of hay and slow quiet scratches.
If we just for a moment considered that animals are more like us than they are different - well I wonder where that might lead.
Photo shows 4 year old Lusitano Rural learning about delicious herbs on a Devon bank.