31/08/2021
Punishment is scientifically tested and it works.
By punishment, I mean anything which makes a behaviour less likely to happen again. Punishment is not only against my values but has lots of side effects in training.
Having a dog who pulls at the lead is very annoying, I know. So, let's say, you decided to use a head collar to stop your dog from doing that. Innocently, you buy the equipment believing the dog won't feel any discomfort or pain. This just, magically, stop your dog from pulling.
As soon as you go on the streets, your dog sees another dog and gets super excited, pull in the lead and the dog feels a pain in the neck and his head turns away by itself. Very odd! Your dog doesn't understand, get confused, come back to your side and keep walking towards the park. You think "Wow, this really works".
Around the main road, your dog sees another dog, he tries to walk faster to reach the other dog and feels that pain in the neck again. "What's happening today? I don't understand. Ā«Frustrated, your dog comes back to your side.Ā» By the 34th time your dog sees another dog and feel the pain in the neck, he's 100% sure!
This is how it's born reactivity! Amazing stuff. Now, human not only has a loose leash walking problem to solve but lunging, barking and biting issues as well. The human will say Ā«Last week my dog was ok and suddenly he became aggressive for no reasonĀ».
Just because it works doesn't mean you should use it. All the things you need to teach your dog can taught with positive reinforcement, which has no side effect, apart from having a happy and obedient dog.
Which habit would you like to change in your dog?