10/08/2023
One of the most important items we need when we train with Positive Reinforcement (R+) and/or Counter Conditioning - is food! Pretty hard to train without it!
Forget about “treats” and “treat training”!!
Food is a Primary Reinforcer and it’s innately valuable to the animal, it doesn’t have to be learnt (conditioned). This means food is an unconditioned reinforcer and is similar to other Primary Reinforcers that are associated with ensuring survival, such as water, shelter and s*x. The great thing is that food is easy and portable.
An important tenet of R+ training is that we never train a hungry animal. We also train with alternative food as physically close as possible and also as similar in value to the food we are offering in our training. In this way, we offer a measure of choice to the equine, as many will not easily walk away from a training session to access alternate food.
Many equines may be afraid to walk away from a training session due to past learning history around humans. It’s not enough to say “the horse can just walk away if they don’t like it or don’t want to participate”. We need to teach the horse that they have a choice and can exercise it, they don’t automatically know this and will leave. It’s also important to remember that if a horse leaves, you may be entering Negative Reinforcement territory, which we want to avoid if our aim is to train with R+.
Often I will even recommend training after the equine has eaten. This is because many equines have an unhappy history around food, such as being deprived, having had to fight over food or have been teased with food, particularly higher value food. Equines can have a love hate relationship with food, certain foods can be associated with unpleasant experiences and trauma and particularly if they’ve ever experienced EGUS (ulcers).
One really important factor in successful R+ training is the type of food. Species appropriate food that is low in sugar and starch, high in fibre and creates lots of chewing and saliva. I recommend using dampened chopped hay (chaff), fibre or hay pellets, rinsed and soaked unmolassed beet pulp or even handfuls of loose hay. This type of food is what equines were designed to eat and it creates pleasure, satiation and relaxation in slowly chewing these types of foods. Forget about Cheerios, carrot coins and sunflower seeds, etc as they are not species appropriate and can often sabotage your training, by creating equines who are barely satisfied and perhaps even frustrated by these small titbits.
Finally, be generous!! Another of the most common pitfalls of people starting out training with food is that they are not generous enough. Be aware of choke, but give a generous handful to begin with and then keep topping it up regularly.
When shaping new behaviours, if you can click and feed every couple of seconds, you’ll have a very happy horse who is nearly continually chewing. As trickle feeders, this is what equines were designed to do and it makes them very happy! Being generous also means we are not withholding in order to wait for a specific behaviour. Continually topping up the food is what keeps the horse wanting to keep engaging and trying.
Here's an example of what an early session looks like where we are teaching the horse the meaning of the click or marker you are using, also how to stay out of our space ("manners") and how generous the trainer needs to be when starting out or when training a new behaviour:
https://youtu.be/DHfPcFMqn2I?si=7T7bddvxEbH_a5Zp
Make sure you have big generous food pouches and stuff them full of high fibre food. Even if you think you’re being generous, check on your equines’ behaviour. Do they look similar to when they’re munching their hay net in their own time, or do they look tense and have their ears back?
Do you think you could throw them a handful in a bucket while you get organised or set things up? Could you throw a few more handfuls each time you give them a break? A couple of handfuls in a few buckets or mats scattered around while you set up your camera to film your sessions? Do you continually feed your horse when you stop to chat to someone?