19/11/2025
SHOULD I STAY OR SHOULD I GO NOW…
What should you do when you're faced with an incoming off-lead dog?
For us folk who share our lives with dogs who aren't fans of other dogs, it's a question that we unfortunately have to navigate on a semi-regular basis.
Your options are varied, but they basically boil down to: 1) get the hell out of there, or 2) stay and mitigate the sh*tshow that’s about to unfold.
Let’s be honest, option 1 is rarely possible. And sometimes it’s not even the best option.
Like when me and dog walking doggo Juno were up on Heptonstall moor in the summer, and a dog rocked up out of nowhere, owner nowhere in sight. We tried walking in the opposite direction but he followed us - he just wanted to play, and he wasn’t taking Juno’s petrified barking and lunging as anything but a signal that she too was really really keen.
She was not.
But then lo and behold: the owner eventually appeared in the distance - in a panic to be fair - and called her dog back. Who ignored her, because who wouldn’t when you’ve found a new best friend 🤷♀️
And so even though every fibre of my being wanted to just get Juno out of there, the best thing to do was to walk towards the owner, so that the dog who was still harassing Juno would follow.
(Once we caught up with each other, we then had another 10 minutes of her trying to get a lead on her dog, during which time me and Juno still couldn’t leave, otherwise he would have just followed us again, but that’s a whole other saga we don’t have time for right now 🙈)
Long story short, sometimes you just have to deal with the sh*tshow.
But there ARE things you can do.
What you choose to do might depend on…
▶️ your dog - what they’re likely to do
▶️ the other dog - what they’re likely to do, which might be hard to figure out, but their body language and behaviour as they approach might give you some clues
▶️ the other owner - whether you can even see them, whether they’re paying attention, whether they look like they give a crap that their dog is approaching another dog
▶️ the environment - is there something you can use to create a visual barrier, or better still a physical barrier, between you and the other dog
Potential options:
⭐️ Shouting over to the other owner and asking them to call their dog back. Some people genuinely don’t realise that it’s not fair or sensible to let an off-lead dog approach an on-lead dog. Or they do understand, but just haven’t been paying attention to their dog and spotted what’s going on. (I’ve found that “please call your dog back” works much better than “please put your dog on a lead” as that seems to be more likely to get people’s backs up)
⭐️ If your dog is small enough, and it will make them feel better not worse, you can pick them up. The whys and wherefore of that are a post in itself, which is handy as it’s one I’ve written before:
https://www.facebook.com/ParkerAndPoochDogServices/posts/406624465447979
⭐️ Before now I’ve grabbed a dog by the collar and held onto them until their owner has arrived, and meanwhile let out Alice’s lead so she could move away and get the distance away she wanted. (I’m confident in judging whether this is a good idea or not - based on the other dog’s body language - but if you’re not, don’t). I’ve also tried doing this and the dog has run off because they didn’t want to get grabbed - great, job done.
⭐️ An umbrella to use as a barrier ?? I see this recommended sometimes. I don’t know how many hands these people have, but if you have a dog on a lead who is about to bark and lunge, I’m not sure which spare hand you’re using to open and wield the umbrella…. I would have thought you were much less likely to be able to remain in control of your dog doing this. Also one of them might get injured by the pointy bits, plus the novel sight might make the other dog more excited or scared, and become more volatile. Having said all that, if it works for you - go for it.
⭐️ Throw treats for the other dog ?? I see this recommended a lot. Again it feels like there’s more risks than benefits here - your dog may want to get to the treats too, then there’s a competition for resources and a potential escalation of the situation. Or if you do get away while the other dog is eating the food, they’re more than likely to run back to you looking for more snacks when they’ve finished.
⭐️ One thing I do love, and highly recommend, is an policeman's stop. A policeman's stop is when you stand tall with your arm/hand out in front of you like a policeman and yell “STOP”. It works best with bigger dogs and those approaching at sp*ed.
And you need to practise this when no-one is around, because I can guarantee you will feel like a dick doing it the first time 🤣 But I can also guarantee when you do it for real and the dog that’s charging towards you shudders to a halt, you will feel ten feet tall and downright invincible 💪👊
⭐️ And the other thing I do thoroughly recommend - even though it’s bloomin’ hard sometimes - is staying calm and not losing your 💩 with the other owner. Your dog will thank you for it, and it will make the whole situation less fraught. Not gonna lie, I don’t always manage this 🙄
What have I missed? What are your other go-to moves when the inevitable happens?