09/04/2025
Thank you Koven Moodley - Smart Pet Behaviour for this post.
WHY I DON'T USE PUNISHMENT (P+) IN DOG TRAINING OR BEHAVIOUR MODIFICATION
Punishment-based dog training or behaviour modification often fails because it doesn't teach dogs what to do, instead, it only suppresses unwanted behaviors, leading to fear, anxiety, and potentially aggression, while also damaging the bond between dog and owner.
Some consequences of positive punishment are:
1. Punishment doesn't teach desired behaviors
Punishment focuses on what the dog shouldn't do, not what it should do, leaving the dog confused and unsure of what is expected.
2. Punishment creates fear and anxiety
Punishing a dog can lead to fear and anxiety, as they may associate the punishment with you or the situation, potentially causing them to become fearful or aggressive.
3. Punishment damages relationships
Punishment can damage the bond between you and your dog, as they may begin to distrust or fear you.
4. Punishment doesn't address the root cause of the behaviour
Punishment only addresses the symptom of the problem, not the underlying cause, which can lead to the behaviour resurfacing later.
5. Punishment can backfire
Dogs may learn to avoid situations or people associated with punishment, rather than learning the desired behaviour.
6. Punishment requires constant supervision and consistency
Punishment needs to be immediate, consistent, and severe enough to be effective, which can be difficult to achieve and may lead to unintended consequences.
Punishment can be, inter-alia:
Yanking, pushing or shoving
Corrections
Yelling and scolding
Finger pointing
Spray bottles
Use of choke chains, prong collars, shock collars , head harnesses, no pull harnesses or martingale collars
Withholding food, water or a warm place to rest
Withholding comfort when your dog is scared
Early pinching
Kneeing
Intimidation of any kind
Hitting or smacking
Forcing a dog to confront his fears or to 'get over it'
Saying "No!"
Saying "stop it!"
100% Positive reinforcement and not balanced training, is definitely effective in the long run, so instead of punishing unwanted behaviours, focus on rewarding and reinforcing desired behaviors which is a more effective and humane way to train dogs or modify behaviour.
Find a force-free, positive reinforcement, ethical trainer or behaviour professional to help you understand how to best work with your dog. Be aware of those punting the words 'balanced' and 'corrections' while throwing treats at your dog - they are not ethical professionals.
Note 1 - I am not going to argue with balanced trainers. I'm here to use my knowledge, education, skills and compassion to help my clients and their dogs. You do you and I will do me. Also be assured that I won't come onto your page to argue with you on your philosophies, ethics and knowledge.
Note 2 - this post does not cover emergencies like your dog running into the road or engaged in any dangerous situation. This post is about being proactive as opposed to reactive. It is not about setting your dog up for failure but rather to give them the skills to be successful with your assistance when confronted with a trigger.
Some sources:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1558787817300357
https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2053&context=hc_sas_etds
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7743949/ #:~:text=These%20findings%20indicate%20that%20aversive,and%20outside%20the%20training%20context.
https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2017-46333-003
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318577941_Do_aversive-based_training_methods_actually_compromise_dog_welfare_A_literature_review
www.smartpetbehaviour.com
www.coape.org
www.cabti.org