11/09/2024
Guys Can We Learn From Tina's Experience?
I'm going to state something that's going to upset some people.
I am a breeder of German Shepherd Dogs since 1986, and I am also heavy into the rescue of dogs. Before anyone slams me for being a breeder, know that I am very responsible and ethical, and I always have been.
I am so sick and tired of rescues and others making excuses for bad - tempered dogs. Saying the dog "must've been abused". Most of the time, that is not the case at all . Most dogs are born either dominate, aggressive, confident, shy, or fearful. It's called inherited temperament. I see it in the litters of puppies that I have had. You have the dominant ones, and you have the middle ones that are confident and out-going, and then you have the shy ones, sometimes all in the same litter. And also the occasional bully. They're all raised the same way. Without being a breeder, one would not know this.
There have been many cases of dogs that were severely abused , where the abuse was actually proven, not speculated. Yet some
of those dogs had excellent inherited temperaments, and when put in stable homes, they had no issues at all. A big example of this would be Michael Vick's pit bulls. After they were confiscated, most of them were placed with families who said they were the sweetest dogs . And then there have been extremely aggressive or dominate dogs, ( I had one) that people have tried everything with , such as neutering, training, socializing, and even drugs, and the dog is still aggressive. That dog was likely the dominate, assertive one in the litter. This is not to say that dominate- assertive dogs are bad, but mix that with instability and you have a real problem.
I once had a three-month-old black male German shepherd puppy brought to me for boarding, and I warned the people when they came to pick him up that they would have to be very careful with this dog when he grew up because I saw the extreme aggression in him already, and he wasn't abused. When I would
pick him up to take him in the house , he would stiffen and actually snarl at me , and this was a three month old puppy!
Do you think that the thousands of Chihuahuas that are notorious for biting have all been abused? It is temperament that was there when they were born.
I'm not saying that abuse can't cause any adverse reactions, but people shouldn't jump to the conclusion that dogs have been abused , and with love , everything will be all right. You could be putting dangerous dogs in homes thinking that love will solve everything, when the underlying issue is inherited temperament. Temperament can be disguised, especially by an experienced trainer, but it will always resurface when the dog is stressed.
I have been training dogs for almost 40 years. What I see time and time again is that you can take a sound dog , with a good inherited temperament , that has been in his backyard his whole life , and take him out in public for the first time, and you would think that the dog had been socialized. And you can take dogs that people have taken everywhere trying to socialize and rehabilitate, and the dogs are still nut cases.
— Tina Lamey