19/09/2024
Exposure therapy and systematic desensitisation are both effective methods for helping dogs overcome fear or anxiety towards specific stimuli, but they differ in their approaches.
Exposure Therapy involves gradually and repeatedly exposing a dog to the feared object or situation in a controlled manner, aiming to reduce their fear response over time. The focus is on getting the dog accustomed to the stimulus through direct experience, with the goal of reducing their overall anxiety and improving their comfort level in the presence of the fear inducing trigger.
Systematic Desensitisation combines gradual exposure with relaxation training. You would start with relaxation training at home first. Depending on the family’s ability to implement it, I often suggest Dr Karen Overall’s breathing protocol (you can find it in her veterinary textbook, “Manual of Clinical Behavioural Medicine for dogs and cats”). This is a valuable tool for helping dogs manage anxiety and stress. This technique is useful in managing stress and anxiety in dogs by teaching them how to regulate their breathing and calm themselves. It’s often integrated into broader behaviour modification plans, especially when working on reducing fear or anxiety. It does take time for the dog to understand and link the behaviour of breathing with relaxation, so you have to be patient. For more information on this fascinating technique see this link if you don’t have access to her book: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdffTkxqlZQ
Once your dog learns the breathing technique you would then start by exposing the dog to the feared stimulus at a very low intensity while simultaneously teaching them to relax. The process involves creating a step-by-step plan of fear-inducing situations, you start by exposing the dog to the least intimidating version of their fear and gradually move up to more challenging situations. Each step is carefully planned to ensure that the dog can handle it without becoming overwhelmed.
This process works by introducing the dog to the feared object or scenario in a highly controlled manner. The idea is to build the dog’s confidence gradually, moving from one level of fear to the next only when they’re emotionally ready. This method helps the dog learn to adapt to the situation and learn that the situation isn’t as threatening as they originally believed. The aim is to replace the fear response with a neutral one.
For instance, if a dog is afraid of other dogs, you might start by having them observe another dog from a distance at which they are comfortable - which might be quite a large distance at the start. The goal is to keep the dog below their threshold — the point at which their fear becomes too strong, leading to a reaction such as barking, growling, or trying to flee. Over time, with consistent and calm exposure, the dog’s fear response decreases as they become desensitised to the stimulus.
The key to successful exposure therapy is gradual progression. Once the dog appears more relaxed in the initial situation, you can slowly increase the intensity of the exposure, such as decreasing the distance to the other dog or allowing for slightly longer durations of visual interaction. Importantly, the dog should always remain within a zone where they can stay calm, as pushing them too fast may trigger their fear, causing setbacks.
Another important aspect of exposure therapy is the pairing of positive reinforcement. This means adding something the dog enjoys/ likes to increase the likelihood of desired behaviour, which in this case the desired behaviour is the dog not reacting and being neutral.
Giving treats, praise, or other forms of reward when the dog remains calm in the presence of the feared stimulus, the dog begins to associate that previously feared situation with positive experiences. Over time, this can change the emotional response to the trigger from fear to one of confidence or neutrality.
Exposure therapy requires patience and consistency, as dogs can’t simply "get over" their fears overnight. Forcing a dog to face their fears too quickly, often referred to as "flooding," can actually worsen anxiety. Instead, working at the dog’s pace and celebrating the small victories can lead to long-term improvements in their behaviour.
Understanding the environment, recognising your dog's limits, and using effective management and reinforcement, exposure therapy can help fearful dogs build confidence and handle their triggers more effectively.
While both methods involve gradual exposure to feared stimuli, systematic desensitisation incorporates relaxation techniques and a structured step-by-step plan to help the dog learn to cope in situations they find distressing.
If you are struggling with a dog who becomes easily distressed, please find a qualified science-based behaviourist or trainer who can help support you and your dog.