04/07/2023
How We See, What We See
How we see, and what we see, depends on where we come from, what our previous experience was, and what our education is. All of this affects our perspective. For example, a local Amish farrier, John Beechy, and I share a client. I trim the barefoot horses; he does the shod horses. The owner asked me to meet at John's shop so the three of us could collaborate on a horse she had concerns about. Turns out, she had agreed to drive her horse 100 miles in three months. Her perspective - Is my horse up to it/what do I need to feed/will my horse go lame/do my farriers think this is ok? My perspective - What an awesome goal! My four horses combined don't go a hundred miles in a year! The Amish perspective - John looked a little concerned and drew me off to the side. “Do I understand her correctly? That's only one mile a day!” Three different people; three different backgrounds; three different perspectives. None of us were wrong.
Part of my job as a farrier is to ask my owners lots of questions. Often owners tell me they know nothing trimming or shoeing, and they drop the ball in my lap. While their statement may be true, owners know their horses intimately, daily, all year long. I need to ask the right questions to draw the needed information out. Owners should be directing lots of questions at their farriers, vets and trainers. When we all share our perspectives, we find ourselves set up for success, and our horses are much better for it.
Let's begin with a comparison of conformation and posture. Conformation is bone structure; how the bones meet and interface at each joint. We think of conformation in terms of legs, but it is much more than that. Look at a side view of the entire horse. The top line, the shape of the rump, the slope of the shoulder, how the tail sets on, how the neck ties in, are all conformation. With few exceptions, farriers cannot “change” conformation.
Posture is how a horse stands. For a moment, let's look at our own posture. If we are exhausted, I mean flat worn out, we tend to hang our heads. Our shoulders slump, we move slowly and often drag our feet. The same is true if we are mentally depressed. Our horses, and their posture, react the same way.
Farriers have a huge impact on the posture of our horses. Again, let's look at ourselves. Put on a flat pair of shoes intended for walking, or a pair of shoes with pointy toes and 4 inch heels. Both styles are designed to affect our posture; how we stand and how we walk. Choose the first and after walking 1 mile, we are still comfortable, still smiling and still having fun. Choose the latter, and in a short period of time the feet hurt. Women are tough and suck it up, so the pain soon moves up into the lower back, and from there up between the shoulder blades. Think how differently you NOW move and stand. Does all that pain make you feel just a little grumpy? The same is true for our horses.
Let's look at the other extreme. Put on a pair of swim fins, or a pair of Ronald McDonald shoes. Now we have problems picking up our feet and taking a step forward. In horse terms, “breakover “ has been greatly affected, and we soon feel that as pain in our ankles, knees and hips. The same is true of our horses. With both extremes, high heels or long clown toes, our balance is immediately and negatively affected. Try walking in deep footing or over rough ground and you will feel what your horse feels!
In terms of posture, high heels tip us forward, causing us to arch our back, moving our shoulders back and tipping our head forward. It doesn't take long before we hurt! Wearing long toes and we lean forward at the waist, throwing our shoulders back and lifting our chin high. Again, we will soon hurt.
Long toes or high heels, our horses are affected the same way as we are, both in posture and in pain. Compare Photos 1 and 2. In Photo 1, taken before the feet were trimmed, the yellow line is the slope of the pasturn. The blue line is centered on the cannon bone and intersects the ground well behind heels of the foot, giving little support to the leg and upper body. Note how the entire leg is leaning forward.
Photo 2 is after trimming. Immediately the leg is much more upright. The blue line intersects the ground much closer to the heel of the foot and the slope of the hoof, the yellow line, almost matches the slope of the pasturn. All photos in this article were taken by CCourtney Trailrider, and she is also the farrier.
This horse happens to be barefoot, but the principles are identical for horses with shoes. Also, I am not advocating that the freshly trimmed feet in Photo 2 are correct. They are not, but it is a huge improvement over what we see in Photo 1, before trimming! It consistently takes 3 or 4 trimming or shoeing cycles to change a wonky foot into a well balanced foot. But look at the difference just one trimming can do!
Now let's look at the entire profile of the horse, again, both before trimming and after. Compare the top line in the two photos. Note how the horse stands camped under behind and with a hollowed out back in Photo 3, before trimming. After trimming, Photo 4, to rebalance the feet, the horse stands much wider behind with the hind legs squarely underneath the hips, and with a much flatter top line.
When a horse is brought to me with wonky, mismatched, unbalanced and asymmetrical feet, I consistently find compromised posture with sore, achy legs and a sore back, typically just behind where the saddle sits, the lumbar area. With or without shoes, trimming the feet to achieve better anatomical balance produces immediate improvement in posture. In the week following the hoof rebalance, horses move better, and move more, as pain in their joints and muscles diminishes. The horse in the accompanying photos is better with this initial trim, but still is not “right". Barefoot or shod, it takes 3 to 4 trim cycles to set a horse up correctly. After that, you just maintain!