03/21/2025
My dog only listens when I have a treat!!
Is this your situation? Let's chat about reinforcement and building strong, reliable behavioral responses.
First, we need to identify what went wrong. The most common reason for a dog to only respond when a treat is in front of him is because you never changed your reinforcement schedule. More on that to come. But, there is a definite order to how you should be training your dog. If you only ever hold a treat out for your dog to see, then ask for a behavior, we are actually bribing him, not necessarily teaching him. Now, when we are first training a new cue, we may use luring, which does require putting a treat in front of your dog. However we want to phase that out as soon as possible! The order of operations, so to speak, should be: cue (ask for a behavior verbally), hand signal (if you have one), mark the correct behavior, and then reward. The treat should arguably appear out of nowhere. You must execute perfect timing on your mark, and you absolutely must reward your dog each time in the early stages of learning. Think of a reward as paying your dog for a job well done.
Now that we know the why, how do we address this issue? If you have poisoned or overused the cue word (two additional reasons a cue may not work without a super yummy treat in sight), you may have to start over with a different word and re-teach the behavior. If you are still in the early stages of training, address your reinforcement schedule. The reinforcement schedule is basically how frequently you reward your dog. In the beginning you want to reward every correct attempt, or, every successive approximation (smaller increments of a behavior, used when shaping instead of luring) of a final behavior. You must be consistent to help your dog learn. As he shows that he is understanding your cue(s) you will want to move to a variable reinforcement schedule. This means that you do NOT reward each successful behavior, but rather, you offer rewards at random intervals. So, you may reward the 2nd correct attempt, then the 5th correct attempt, then the 1st correct attempt, and so on. This works to actually strengthen the behavior as it 1) prevents extinction, and 2) keeps your dog's motivation up as he knows that eventually a reward WILL come. In difficult training scenarios (such as when you increase distractions) you may have to temporarily move back to a continuous reinforcement schedule by rewarding every attempt.
So, now that you are on a variable reinforcement schedule you should see strong behavioral responses to your cues. You can slowly increase the time between each reward, but, the key is to never completely stop rewarding. As mentioned above, think of a reward as payment for a job. If we completely take away a paycheck, why would your dog continue to offer the behavior? Would you work for free? However this doesn't mean you have to use treats forever. If your dog is responsive to a particular toy, physical affection, or even the environment, you can use these options for a reward. The caveat here is that your dog determines what is rewarding, not us. This means that if your dog doesn't have strong play drive or enjoys physical affection, but has a strong response to treats, then it would be most beneficial to continue to use treats. This also means that in some scenarios we have to increase the value of a reward, as when we are making the training scenario more difficult. So, where in some cases a good scratch might work, in others you may have to use hotdogs or boiled chicken. Or, whatever your dog loves the most.
If you need help teaching new behaviors or proofing current behaviors, shoot us a message!