03/24/2022
Is peer pressure in the horse world the reason for the lack of safety?
I have had a few interactions with students over the last week that had me ask myself this question.
I deal with safety and confidence issues on a daily basis, and much of the time I look for the mechanics behind what a rider or handler is doing that results in unsafe behaviour. Much of the time I am reiterating what I have already taught the student, and I do understand that it takes repetition for new behaviours to become second nature, so I try to patiently correct the person and encourage them to get repetitions in place.
It has, however, been a theme through my career that students are bullied and flooded with unsolicited advice by more conventional riders. The riders offering this advise normally have far worse issues to deal with with their own horses, but use "their experience" as a tool to pressure the student.
"Just get on and ride!", Hospital or back on", and "Falling off is just a part of riding horses" are some of the things that get forced onto riders trying something differently.
None of these statements have any virtue. I know those taught this way will tell me that if you don't get back on immediately you will have a permanent fear of horses. This is simply not true. Getting back in to a dangerous situation after you have just been hurt is more likely to cause compounded PTSD than it is to increase your bravery, but the biggest fault with this mentality is that it reinforces the habit of not addressing what went wrong. There is always a reason for a fall. If the horse bucked, spooked, reared, bolted.. anxiety or pain are likely the reasons. This needs to be addressed before a rider gets back on.
I have a long list of regular students that are either coming back to riding after years of not wanting to do it, or were on the brink of quitting, because of these "mottos "of the equestrian world. I have students that have taken years to rebuild their confidence after they got back on after a fall, only to end up in the hospital after remounting. It is just plain lack of common sense.
So, why do others pressure people on a different path to do what they do?
From safety point of view, you will hear them saying things like: "well I have done that my whole life and I am fine". These are the same people who post meme after meme about their daily regiment of ibuprofen and how long it takes for them to walk up straight after getting out of bed.
Someone making an effort to be safer makes them subconsciously feel that they need to defend what they have always done. This, as always, comes down to cognitive dissonance. Someone else having success doing something different challenges their core beliefs and our brains are wired to defend those core beliefs for fear of having to relearn everything we know.
This also applies to welfare issues. For example, someone considering a horses anxiety, pain or natural needs will highlight that they may not be considering those crucial aspects. Without saying a word to them, they may feel under attack out of sheer guilt. What better way to defend themselves from your non-existent attack that trying to discredit science.
I recommend finding a supportive group of people that follow the same principles as you do, and running your doubts by your instructor. I realise the number of instructors offering empathetic training techniques means many people get occasional in person lessons and regular online lessons, but trust me, your horsemanship instructor has heard every bullying tactic in the book 1000 times and can reassure you. Even with this it takes a fair amount of willpower and resilience to stand up to these attacks. These viewpoints still exist purely because they have been oppressively protected in the face of overwhelming evidence that they have no place in the modern world...Your resilience and asking for support could be the thing that helps make them an embarrassing memory, rather than a continuing safety concern!