11/08/2025
Did you know I teach in the psychology department at CT State- Tunxis? I have for the last 11 yearsđ€ The nerd in me loves to see the Milgram Experiment referenced in the horse world, but the horsewoman in me wishes it didnât have to be.
Itâs our job to be our horses advocate- sometimes this means uncomfortably questioning authority for their benefit. Any professional who makes you think your questions are dumb or your feelings are invalid doesnât need to be an authority figure on your team đ€·đŒââïž
The Milgram Experiment and Obedience in Everyday Training
Did you know one of the most famous psychology experiments helps explain why good people sometimes follow questionable advice from âexpertsâ when it comes to training animals?
What Was the Milgram Experiment?
In the 1960s, psychologist Stanley Milgram discovered that ordinary people would administer what they believed were painful electric shocks to othersâsimply because an authority figure in a lab coat told them to. The lesson? Humans are wired to obey perceived authority, even when it means going against their own values or instincts.
What Does This Have To Do with Animal Training?
In training barns, clinics, or dog classes, the âauthority figureâ might be a trainer, instructor, or so-called expert. If that expert says, âYou must use this tool,â âYou have to use pressure or punishment to get respect,â or, âItâs okay, all the professionals do itââmany of us will comply, even if it feels wrong in our gut.
Maybe youâve witnessed a harsh technique, or seen someone push a horse past what felt safe, and stayed silent because âthe trainer knows best.â Thatâs Milgramâs obedience at workânot a lack of compassion, but a normal human response to authority.
Why Does It Matter?
Recognizing this can empower us to pause and reflect:
Am I following instructions just because someone said so?
Does this align with my ethics and what I know about animal welfare?
How does the horse appear to feel in this situation?
A Different Way Forward:
True leadership in horsemanship is about understanding, not blind obedience. We canâand shouldâask questions, trust our intuition, and seek out humane, science-based methods. When in doubt, listen to your horse as much as the human âauthority.â
Letâs remember: The real authority in any relationship is compassion, respect, and a willingness to question what doesnât feel right. Horses depend on our courage to speak up and choose betterâno matter whoâs watching.
Learn more at https://stormymay.com