The Sugared Pony

Home
United States
East Islip, NY
The Sugared Pony

We specialize in custom treats for both horses & dogs!🐴🐶💕

03/07/2025

Although we announced we were closing, I never disclosed why!
I think Michael’s shirt in the first photo gives It away but in case you still don’t get It, swipe for the rest of the photos!

Maybe when life settles I will get back into business but until then, I want to thank you all from the bottom of my heart💙🩶

09/09/2024

I just wanted to come on here & let everyone know that The Sugared Pony is officially closing! Being back to work & having so much going on, It is time!
I have one big order for Rider’s Choice in Ronkonkoma, NY for October & then one custom order for a friend & then we will officially be closing our kitchen!

I want to thank you all from the bottom of my heart for the last almost 3 years! Thank you for allowing me to bake cookies for your beloved babies & for supporting our small business! 💕

Who knows, maybe we will be back when life slows down!💕

08/18/2024

Who doesn’t love cupcakes?!

08/09/2024

We will be starting our baking for the this week!! Get your orders in! We’re doing something really special for & can’t wait to share them!

We will also be making a bunch of “Summers are for Horse Shows” boxes that would be the perfect gift to your student or pony/horse for all their hard work this summer!

08/08/2024

I’ve been thinking of branching into cookies for human consumption! Would people be interested in that?

08/06/2024

We’re so close to 900 followers!
Help us get there & be entered in a chance for a giveaway!
1. Make sure you follow us
2. Like this post
3. Share this post on your story
4. Tag 3 friends you think would love our treats in the comments

Giveaway will be a $50 voucher for any treats you’d like (custom sets not included)

08/03/2024

Feels like Summer💕

07/22/2024

We have availability the next two weeks for cookies!!

Here’s what you can order:
⭐️Cookie Donuts (6 cookies per order) - $15.00
⭐️Mini Poptarts (15 cookies per order) - $18.00
⭐️Ice Cream (6 cookies per order) - $20.00
⭐️Weekends are for Horse Shows (4 cookies per order) - $15.00
⭐️Shark Attack (3 cookies per order) - $18.00
⭐️Pizza Party Pies (8 cookies per pie) - $18.00
⭐️Mini Muffins (12 per order) - $18.00
⭐️Peppermint Cups (12 per order) - $15.00
⭐️Birthday/Celebration Cakes (large cakes only) - $18.00
⭐️Birthday/Celebration Boxes (8 cookies per order) - $25.00
⭐️Mini Cupcakes (12 per order) - $18.00
⭐️Granolove - $8.00 per tray
⭐️Mystery Box - $40.00
⭐️Mini Hearts (12 per order) - $15.00

07/19/2024

Our first official puppy treat taste tester went to heaven tonight 💔 we will miss our Finn so very much

07/17/2024

Custom cookies for 💙

07/06/2024

We are open for 2 more orders for the week of July 10th - July 17th

06/20/2024

UPDATE:
This week is done for orders & we are booked up for July 2nd - July 9th!
We have decided to add an additional week which will be: July 10th - July 17th!

We will continue as planned below: ⬇️

July 23rd - July 29th: available for 5 orders

All of August is open - looking to do at least 3-5 orders per week!

Message me to book now!
For booking August we ask for a $5 deposit via Venmo, Zelle or PayPal

Venmo: TheSugaredPony (if asks for last 4 of phone number 1430)
Zelle: [email protected] or 516-778-1430
PayPal: [email protected]

06/19/2024

If you will be at this weekend be sure to grab these for your prize! & please tag us in your photos!! 💕

06/14/2024

Good Morning!! While baking the other day we baked an extra batch of a new product (mini hearts!)
They are the perfect bite size cookie!!
Message me to claim! 💕

06/10/2024

⭐️ANNOUNCEMENT⭐️

We will be opening up our kitchen for the following dates:
(Please note the beginning of the week is baking & the end of that same week will be decorating & delivery/shipping)

June 12th - June 21st: only opening our books for 3 more orders as we are booked for 2 already

July 2nd - July 9th: available for 5 orders

July 23rd - July 29th: available for 5 orders

All of August is open - looking to do at least 3-5 orders per week!

Message me to book now!
For booking August we just ask for a deposit to secure your spot.

Treats to choose from:
Cookie Donuts (6 cookies per order) - $15.00
Mini Poptarts (15 cookies per order) - $18.00
Ice Cream (6 cookies per order) - $20.00
Weekends are for Horse Shows (4 cookies per order) - $15.00
Shark Attack (3 cookies per order) - $18.00
Pizza Party Pies (8 cookies per pie) - $18.00
Mini Muffins (12 per order) - $18.00
Peppermint Cups (12 per order) - $15.00
Birthday/Celebration Cakes (large cakes only) - $18.00
Birthday/Celebration Boxes (8 cookies per order) - $25.00
Mini Cupcakes (12 per order) - $18.00

All colors will be chosen at random

05/09/2024

We have some exciting news!! Most of you know when I went back to work full time I slowed down with the cookies…well it’s almost the end of the school year which means I’m off all of July & August!
Books are opened now so please start scheduling some orders for then!

Also, another exciting update but my husband, son & I are MOVING!!! we are moving next door to my parents (which is where I bake) but I have a larger kitchen & will be able to go back to making orders regularly, even after I go back to work in September!

Looking forward to more new things & some old things!

Tell me - what kind of treat do you think I should make next?

05/01/2024

Head over to my story to see how you can win a free box of cookies!! Help me design a cookie & a name after Caspian

Caspian whose show name is Chronicles of Narnia is a 6 (almost 7) year old TB

Help help help!

04/29/2024

Taco is here to make a little announcement!!
Due to the rising costs of literally everything we will be increasing our prices!
We have been the cheapest around in gourmet treats & I’d love to keep It that way but we have to find a way to make It a little more cost effective!

Here is the breakdown of some of our regulars!⬇️
Peppermint Cups (12 per order) - $15
Hearts (8 per order) -$15
Mini Poptarts (15 per order) - $18
Cookie Donuts - 6 for $15 / 8 for $17 / 10 for $20
Regular Donuts - 1 for $4 / 3 for $10 / 6 for $22
Granolove (goes by tray but usually 10-15 treats per tray) - $10

Address

Division Avenue
East Islip, NY
11730

Website

http://www.thesugaredpony.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sugared Pony posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Sugared Pony: