11/10/2024
While I love that social media has become so supportive of reading dog body language and being conscious of how dogs communicate with us, the nuance has been completely lost. It is simply not as clearcut as “this is stress, this is joy.”
And it is NOT possible to get a definitive reading on a situation in a 30 second video clip outside of very obvious and extreme situations. Whether it’s a training video, play video, or completely random dog video, I will stand by that same statement.
This is true for a few reasons:
First, all dogs present differently. This can be due to breed specific reasons (ie. german shepherds have a completely different tail set to shiba’s), physical structural reasons, or random specific quirks.
Unless you know a specific dog well enough to know what THEIR body language looks like, everything is only a guess.
Second, context matters. Let’s say a dog is presenting stress signals in a training video. What is that dog’s baseline for stress? Is the training reducing the stress signals over time? Is the dog already a generally stressed out dog?
An ordinarily happy-go-lucky dog that is anxious and overwhelmed in a training video is bad, obviously, but a dog that has SEVERE anxiety issues showing minor stress signals might actually be a massive sign of positive progress. You cannot rule out a snapshot as if the context is irrelevant.
Third, all emotions are two sides of the same coin.
A dog eager to work for a treat is not far off from a dog that is frustrated over not getting it.
A dog that is excited for his ball is not far from a dog that is stressed about when it will be thrown.
Resource guarding often shows positive body language as well as negative body language very close together because the insecurity that leads to guarding is triggered by the enjoyment and value of the item.
Now, that’s not to say body language analysis or breakdown videos aren’t valuable, or that they shouldn’t be made. I myself and constantly evaluating body language subconsciously.
But there must be a distinction between whether a video is being used as a definition or a single example.