11/05/2025
Here I go again...đ¤Łđ
Most people donât realize that selling real hermit crab food is illegal.
The laws that govern pet food were never written for animals like ours.
All animal food in the United States falls under one system; the Association of American Feed Control Officials, or AAFCO. They decide what species are recognized, what ingredients are allowed, and how every product must be labeled and licensed. Itâs a structure designed to ensure safety and consistency.
But AAFCO only recognizes certain animals, and if they dont have a nutrient profile recognized, the dietary requirements default to dogs. Thereâs no legal category for hermit crab food.
To get a feed license, every ingredient has to come from AAFCOâs pre approved list, and thatâs where the system truly fails.
The list was built for mammals and birds, not crustaceans. It doesnât include chitin from exoskeletons, coral calcium, leaves; the very things hermit crabs rely on for survival.
So if you follow the law, your product is nutritionally meaningless. If you meet the animalâs needs, youâre out of compliance.
Thatâs why small makers call their products "Treats" or "Suppliments" But by law, anything intended to be eaten by an animal is feed, and feed must come from a licensed, inspected commercial kitchen; not a home, not a hobby space, not anywhere near pets. Each recipe and label has to be approved before it can legally cross hands. The system simply wasnât built for small, specialized care.
Meanwhile, large companies can sell standardized diets that meet regulations but endanger the animalâs health.
The solution isnât to ignore compliance; itâs to update it.
We need feed laws that acknowledge exotic species and allow natural, species specific ingredients to be legally defined and tested.
Compliance shouldnât be the barrier, it should be the path forward.
Until that happens, the best thing we can do is be transparent. Show whatâs in our mixes. Explain our process. Educate others. The goal isnât to work around the system; itâs to build one that finally recognizes the animals that live beyond it.