12/28/2023
Hello everyone. Rick Capone here with the 90th installment of our Old Friends’ Throwback Thursday Memories. This week we remember Star Plus (Arg.), a horse born and raced in Argentina before coming to the United States to race, and who had a hard time realizing his retirement.
However, thanks to his owner, Earle Mack, once he arrived at Old Friends for his retirement, he not only seemed to love it, but he made the most of it, endearing himself to everyone on the farm, as well as visitors who stopped by on tours.
Bred by Claudio Javier Valle and Marc Valle, Star Plus, who was by Alpha Plus--Nannar (Arg.), by Big Play, was foaled in Argentina on July 18, 2003.
Note: Star Plus raced at a time when Equibase did not post its race charts, so I was not able to find a lot of things such as early trainers and owners.
Star Plus began his racing career in 2006 as a 3-year old in Argentina, and got his first win in his first start in a maiden race at San Isidro on July 2. Then, following a 12th in his next start, the Miguel Cane (G2) at Hipodromo Argentino De Palermo on Aug. 18, he got his next win at that same track in what is called in Argentina, a “Winner” race on Sept. 24.
The beautiful bay stallion with the large star on his forehead raced two more times that year and finished fifth in the Palermo at Hipodromo Argentino De Palermo on Nov. 11, and fourth in the Joaquin S. de Anchorena (G1) at San Isidro on Dec. 16.
In all, he had two wins, three seconds, and $26,770 in earnings in eight starts in 2006.
In 2007 as a 4-year old, while still racing in Argentina, Star Plus started the year off with three second-place finishes. The first one came at San Isidro in the America (G2) on March 25. The next two came at the Hipodromo Argentino De Palermo; the first in the Benito Villanueva (G2) on April 29, and the second in the De Las Americas-OSAF (G1) on May 1.
In his next race, he finished third in the 9 de Julio (G2) at San Isidro on July 7, then bounced back and won a Winner at Hipodromo Argentino De Palermo on July 30.
He followed that with three more second-place finishes in a row. The first was at Hipodromo Argentino De Palermo in the General San Martin (G1) on Aug. 20, while the next two were at San Isidro. The first came in the Ecuador (G2) on Sept. 9, and the second came in the San Isidro (G1) on Oct. 7
In his next race, Star Plus scored his biggest career win when he captured the Joaquin S. de Anchorena (G1) at San Isidro on Dec. 15. Interestingly, he beat future Old Friends’ retiree Jade Hunter in the race.
That win would be not only his last race of the year, but his last race in Argentina. He finished the year with two wins, three seconds, one third, and $54,636 in earnings in six starts
To start his 5-year old season in 2008, Star Plus was purchased by Earle Mack and moved to the United States where he raced for Mack from 2008-2010 and was first trained by Ken McPeek.
In his first start for them, he finished fifth in allowance optional claiming race at Churchill Downs on July 3. Then in his next race he finished fourth in the Duke of Magenta Stakes (Listed) at Saratoga on Aug. 9, and then had a second-place finish in the Turfway Park Fall Championship Stakes (G3) at Turfway Park on Sept. 6.
Next up, Star Plus won an allowance race at Keeneland on Oct. 12, and then finished out his race year with a fourth in the River City Handicap (G3) at Churchill Downs on Nov. 22.
He finished 2008 with one win, one second, and $59,505 in earnings in five starts
In 2009 as a 6-year old, Star Plus did not race at all. He came back in 2010 as a 7-year old now under the care of Angel Penna Jr, who trained him for Mack.
All three of his races that year were at Gulfstream Park. In his first start, he finished second in an allowance optional claiming on Jan. 27, then followed that with a seventh in the Canadian Turf Stakes (G3) on Feb. 20. He bounced back in his next race and won an allowance optional claiming race on March 28 under a hand ride by jockey Rajiv Maragh. However, he came out of that race with a severe ankle injury and was retired.
For the year he had one win, one second, and $33,210 in earnings in three starts, and with his retirement, his career record was six wins, eight seconds, one third, and $176,503 in earnings in 26 starts.
According to his obituary on the Old Friends website, it was at this point that Star Plus’ life got, shall we say, interesting. The obit read:
“With his final race in the books, Mack’s plan was to retire Star Plus so he could enjoy the rest of his life. However, the horse’s road to retirement was a long and hard fought one to achieve.
“It began when Mack was advised that there was some interest in Star Plus by a small breeding farm, and he agreed to let them have him. However, he made one major stipulation, which he put in writing in the contract that stated Star Plus was never to be raced again. And, if they no longer wanted the horse, Mack should immediately be notified so that a suitable retirement home could be found for him.
“However, in 2011, Mack discovered that his horse’s new owner/trainer, George Iacovacci, Sr., had put Star Plus back in training and planned to race him. And, so began Mack's quest to get his former horse back before he got hurt, or worse, while racing once again.
“In all, Star Plus raced four times for Iacovacci at three different tracks, Mt. Pleasant, Mountaineer, and Parx Racing, and finished last in all four races.
“In the meantime, every time Mack saw that Star Plus was going to race, he contacted horse racing officials in those states and tracks to let them know of the horse’s medical condition and requested that the horse not be allowed to race. In addition, with the help of a number of people, including Maggie Moss, a well-known attorney and respected thoroughbred owner, letters were also sent to officials saying the same thing and requesting that the horse not be allowed to race. However, all three tracks denied the requests.
“Finally, Mack took matters into his own hands, and after the horse’s fourth race, an allowance optional claiming race at Parx Racing on Jan. 28, 2012, negotiations were held, and with the help of some others, Mack purchased Star Plus back.
“Then, with his horse safely back under his ownership, Mack made arrangements with Michael, and donated his horse to Old Friends to enjoy his long-awaited, well-earned retirement. Star Plus arrived at the farm on July 1, 2012, along with a generous donation by Mack to Old Friends to ensure the care of his horse.”
In the Old Friends blog, longtime volunteer Beth Tashery Shannon talked a little about Star Plus’ personality. In part, she wrote:
“It wasn’t just his strong, handsome looks, or that supernova of a star (plus some) on his face. It was his irrepressible energy and joy in life, and his nonstop mischievous friendliness. If a horse ever had a sense of humor (and some definitely do), Star Plus did. He kept that sense of play and total confidence throughout his life.
“In his first role as a meeter and greeter of tours, Star Plus gave us a chance to familiarize visitors with the story of this willing athlete who’d given his best and the owner who’d overcome difficulties to do the right thing for the horse. We’ve had others since with similar stories, and awareness of such situations can help other horses. The memorable personality of Star Plus made him perfect for the role, but he didn’t stop at that. To him, tours were invented specially so that he could get treats, show off, and have fun. Even with champions on the tour, it was Star Plus who many fell in love with, and no wonder. Michael wasn’t immune to his charm either. Star Plus was one of his favorites.”
Personally, I remember two things about Star Plus during his retirement at Old Friends. The first was that, like many of the other horses on the farm, he was very photogenic. It was almost impossible to take a bad photo of him. And, he always came to the fence for some carrots.
The other memory was the day he snuck up on me and showed his “mischievous friendliness” side. I was walking down the hill next to his paddock … obviously, too close to his paddock … talking to Michael one afternoon. I heard the pounding of hooves, but didn’t think anything of it.
All of a sudden, “bam” he bit me on the shoulder. “Ouch!,” I yelped in surprise. I turned around and there he stood just looking at me with his head tilted a little. I rubbed my shoulder, but I couldn’t be mad at him because he stood there with such a cute expression, and as proud as could be that he “got me.”
Star Plus enjoyed 11 years of retirement at Old Friends, but on Jan. 28, 2023, he died due after suffering a paddock accident. He was 20-years old.
Upon his death, Michael said, “Star Plus was so much fun. We ran together (he always won, of course) and he seemed overjoyed with himself. Smart. Whimsical. Carefree. In short, a great role model.”
And, in the Old Friends blog, Beth wrote: “We hoped … we would have the pleasure of having Star Plus in our lives for many years to come. His passing was an unexpected shock. His going has torn a hole in our hearts. A hole as big and deep as his big presence. All of us, staff, volunteers, and friends, will always remember him with love.”