05/19/2024
From a professional dog trainer’s standpoint, I agreed with all of this until the last few sentences. The herding instinct and nipping isn’t necessarily easily changed. With enough time and effort it can redirected, but it never goes away, and there will still always be a chance of “intrusive thoughts”, for lack of a better explanation, winning out when a child or other pet runs by the dog. In addition most herding dogs think independently of their handlers, which is a necessary herding skill. This means that they may hear your command and decide that isn’t the best way to handle a situation. This also take a large amount of time and effort. They have high energy, need lots of exercise and space to run, and a job, or you will end up hating this breed. Same thing with Australian Cattle Dogs (heelers) which have become more and more popular, especially since the introduction of the cartoon, Bluey.
Bottom line: if you can’t provide ample exercise, a job, or have small children, pets etc. that you don’t want nipped and herded on occasion… DO NOT get a herding dog. Do your research BEFORE getting a dog.
See this picture? It's an Australian Shepherd HERDING the sheep. See the nip? The push with her teeth/muzzle? She's HERDING, not biting! Some Aussies, especially young ones, may do this to their human - and be tossed out of the house for "biting my kid". The Aussie was herding your kid, slowing the kid down from running thru the house, turning the kid toward a different direction, etc...
So many Aussie end up in shelters because humans misunderstood the breed and, instead of teaching the dog appropriate herding behavior, their natural instinct, they toss the dog out of the house.
Make sure you understand what a bite is and isn't. 9 out of 10 times it was inappropriate herding and easily changed.