The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

04/06/2025

Attention 2025 Graduates! My cookie calendar is already starting to fill up, so if you’re wanting custom cookies for your graduation parties and open houses, don’t delay - order now! See the first two pics for availability and the rest of them for inspiration!

If your date is already booked, don’t fret! Decorated sugar cookies freeze really well. I’d love to make special cookies for your graduate this spring!!

New this year - I now own an edible ink printer, so the sky is the limit when it comes to cookie designs! I can put your graduate’s photo right on the cookies!

Reach out soon, as I’m sure this calendar will be completely full very soon!

04/04/2025

How cute are these!?! My client ordered these for her Snoopy-loving mom’s birthday. Aren’t they adorable?!?

04/02/2025

Printed these on the Eddie for my grandpa’s 87th birthday!

03/28/2025

Easter cookie class COMING SOON! Can’t wait to see you there!

Join The Not Perfect Cookie Co. at McAllister Rec Center on Saturday, April 12 from 3-4:30pm for an Easter Egg Cookie Decorating Class. This is an EGG-celent way to get creative and have fun with your friends and family! Class is $40 per person, with a $5 discount for each additional registrant in the same family. Register online at https://secure.rec1.com/IN/lafayette-parks-recreation-in/catalog or call McAllister at (765) 807-1360.

03/23/2025

I’m not ignoring you… I’m on vacation! Be back soon!

P.S. I’m completely booked up until after Easter. Sorry for any inconvenience.

03/17/2025

Happy St. Patrick’s Day! Delivered these cookies to The Convergence Center at Purdue University this morning. I hope they enjoy!

☘️

03/15/2025

Special birthday request for Ronaldo cookies! I did half on the and half with colorful icings. Happy 6th birthday to Karson! I hope he had the best birthday!

PS. Ladies, I fell into a Ronaldo rabbit hole looking for cool graphics to print. If you haven’t seen them, don’t miss seeing photos of his abs 🤩😍😂

03/15/2025

Totally forgot to get a cute “group” photo of these baby shower cookies… Love the colors, and especially love the pink onesie cookies 😍😍 congrats to Mama-to-be Cornell!

03/06/2025

Life Science cookies! I’d made the human body cookies before, but the cute little microscopes and DNA strands were new ones! I hope the event at went well and that everyone enjoyed the cookies!

03/03/2025

So, just for context… I was a guest of this baby’s dad’s baby shower (like when his mom was pregnant with him!) so now I feel completely ancient 😂👵🏼

It was my pleasure to make these adorable cookies for Asra’s (and Tyson’s) baby shower. I got to use the to print the mustache background and the bear with balloons (pulled from the invitation!) so that was fun. I’m learning a lot of new techniques!

I hope the shower was lots of fun!

03/02/2025

I hope Kaleb had an AMAZING birthday party yesterday! When he requested “Cinderace” cookies, I’ll admit that I had no idea what that meant… 😂 But thanks to Google, I figured it out. I got to use the new Eddie on some of these. What a fun new toy! Happy birthday Kaleb!

02/26/2025

What a cute way to announce to your family that you are expecting!! Congrats to the Barnes family on their little bun in the oven!

02/23/2025

Congratulations to Marcela and Anton on their engagement! When their friends ordered these they had a very special request for the Purdue bell tower with a silhouette of a couple AND a poodle. At first, I was unsure how to pull it off, but I really love the end result! I did email this morning to confirm, but Marcela DID say yes!! Congrats!

02/17/2025

Adorable baby shower cookies!! I just love them…

02/10/2025

On top of that giant hospital order, I also had the honor of creating some cookies for the reigning Miss Indiana University ❤️🤍❤️🤍 She and her mom wanted some cookies to pass out to the judges and contestants at this past weekend’s pageant. I never turn down an IU cookie order… 😍😍 I think they turned out beautifully and I heard from (the now former) Miss IU’s mom that they were a huge hit!

02/10/2025

What a week!! This morning, I delivered 1,120 (1,000 regular and 120 gluten free) cookies to St. Elizabeth Hospital for their 150th anniversary celebration. This was on top of the 175 regular and 24 gluten free cookies I delivered there last Thursday (so they’d have time to get them to their other campuses). I’ve never worked so hard in my life, and I’m pretty proud of myself 🥰 I hope they have a wonderful celebration!

Fun Fact - my first job was in the kitchen/cafeteria at St. Elizabeth Hospital when I was 16. My old boss is still there and I’m so grateful that she thinks of me when a need for cookies arises. Thanks Jennifer! 😘😘

01/30/2025

Who is joining me on February 8 to decorate this adorable set of Valentine's Day cookies!?!?

The The Not Perfect Cookie Co.'s February Valentine's Day class is coming up on Saturday, February 8! Join us from 3-4:30pm to decorate Valentine-themed cookies for your loved one (or for yourself!) 😍 Class is $40 per person, with an additional $5 discount for registrants in the same family. Call McAllister Rec at (765) 807-1360 or register online at https://secure.rec1.com/IN/lafayette-parks-recreation-in/catalog