12/11/2019
I’m writing this in response to my previous post about a healthy bare hoof vs. how a hoof must be trimmed for the application of nailed-on shoes.
I got a lot of feedback in the form of “why do you hate shoes?” “It’s whatever the horse needs” “that shoe is bent, of course it won’t fit that horses hoof!” Etc.
No I do not hate farriers, or shoes. I don’t have some hidden anti-steel agenda. No I don’t think every horse should just have his shoes ripped off without any further to-do. And yes that shoe was slightly bent! BUT THAT WASN’T THE POINT!
As a physical therapist my specialty is biomechanics. My treatments center around improving biomechanics to alleviate pain and improve function.
So when I see something altering those biomechanics in a negative way (hello metal shoes!) that’s when I start to SUGGEST other options.
I had my horse in metal shoes for years. I don’t think anyone who puts shoes on their horse is a bad person, the whole reason they put shoes on is because they think that’s what needs to happen to help their horse!
But here’s why metal is an issue:
Metal doesn’t move. It’s rigid. The hoof capsule is designed to expand and contract as the horse moves. In metal shoes, the back half of the foot cannot function properly. The soft tissue structures (frog, digital cushion, and lateral cartilages) that are designed to take impact and dissipate those forces are instead held out of contact with the ground and are unable to move normally due to constriction by a rigid object.
No, I do not advocate for just taking shoes off. Most horses need a transition period between metal shoes and life barefoot that requires skilled trimming and often booting or glue on flexible shoeing for comfort.
Metal shoes keep horses sound because they are a band-aid type of fix. They hold painful structures off the ground, so the horse feels better. Then those structures continue to atrophy and the horse needs more and more “advanced” shoeing options over the years.
If you don’t have access to or finances to hire a skilled barefoot trimmer, or the desire to make some significant nutrition and lifestyle changes, please leave the shoes on! I’d rather the horse be sound in metal than lame barefoot any day.
That’s all for now! No more room to type!