11/15/2024
I want to nerd out a little today about the gallop as a follow up to my earlier post about the controversy that surrounds the gallop. How many beats in a gallop stride? Does a beat have to be a footfall? Can we feel all the beats of the gallop? Do we feel the beats differently than biomechanical analysis demonstrates? And if a rider's feel of the beats differs from the objective biomechanical evidence of the beats, which is the correct definition of the gallop beats?
The images below clearly show two equestrian athletes using the suspension in the gallop to better accomplish a task, accurately shooting an arrow and hitting a polo ball. Both horses have all fur feet off the ground. Strict scientific evidence would say these riders are not using a beat of the gallop to increase accuracy, but do the riders experience the suspension as a beat in the rhythm of the gait? They must because they train for it even though technically it doesn't exist as a beat.
Here is a list the various takes on the rhythm of the beats in the gallop:
(1) Edweard Muybridge's photographic study - 1, 2a 2b, 3 (4 beats)
(2) Feel experience - 1, 2, 3, suspension pause (4 beats)
(3) 1, 2a 2b, 3, suspension pause (5 beats)
The (3) explanation, I feel, is the weakest. The (1) explanation is fact, but can it be felt? The (2) explanation is experience based and the "fact " of it is in the pictures where the pause beat is being consciously used.
For me the difference here is a Schrödinger's Cat kind of situation (details below), meaning the explanation is both (1) and (2) are real at the same time with the difference being perception. The (2) advocates like me say that at 35mph a rider cannot feel the 2a 2b second beat as two distinct beats. The separation of the 2 second beat footfalls is a blur, and thus the experience of (2) rhythm is 1, blur, 3, suspension pause or 4 beats.
The nerdy end of the road question is, "Is riding a horse a science project or an athletic experience?" For me it's always been the latter because if I cannot use science when I am riding, for me it's irrelevant. My bottom line is that reality is what you can use to accomplish a task with a horse. In the pictures, we see two riders using the pause to make a more accurate shot.
Final note, if you have not galloped extensively, it would be most appropriate to put questions about the gallop in the comments, not imagined ideas of it.
Today so many riders never leave the arena and for them the gallop is an unknown gait. I think it is a shame to ride only 3/4 of the gaits. Each has its unique subtitles that can only be experienced after a great deal of practice. My advice is to learn the gallop when you are young. It's less scary than when you are older.
*Schrödinger's Cat is a famous thought experiment that demonstrates the idea in quantum physics that tiny particles can be in two states at once until they're observed. It asks you to imagine a cat in a box with a mechanism that might kill it. Until you look inside, the cat is both alive and dead at the same time.
*prior post on the nature of the gallop -www.facebook.com/BobWoodHorsesForLife/posts/pfbid02u1BpU1icbQE3ytJnP7ovYzpL8dpE2DUWTp1jzxvxNhuDdtiwFQGgrrnCBueLZn1Zl