08/10/2022
Amen!!
Before I write what I’m going to write, I’m going to start with explaining my perspective and where I’m coming from.
I teach 10+ group classes per week. Not including the other classes we offer. Everything from puppy class to basic level 1 to confidence building, reactive rover, controlled unleashed, level 2 or polite in public. I teach group classes at least 4 days a week.
I do around 10 - 20 private consults every week. Covering everything from manners to dog and baby concerns to severe aggression.
I am at the shelter, every single week, evaluating new dogs, coming up with behavior mod plans for existing dogs, testing dog dog interactions and helping staff.
I live with 10 personal dogs, one foster, and at times a board and train puppy or two. Half of my dogs are rescues, half are purebred purposefully purchased to assist me at work. From toy dogs to a working Belgian shepherd.
I run a senior and hospice rescue out of my home. So far we’ve had over 15 dogs in 3 years come in and pass on here.
I have 2 training facilities. I’ve been doing this for 20 years. I literally live and breathe dogs. They are the first thing I think about when I wake up, and the last thing I see when I go to sleep. I constantly observing them, monitoring them, engaging with them and working with them, or their humans, in every way shape and form.
Yes. I know it’s a lot. But that’s my point.
I’ve learned a lot, I am still learning a lot, and last night on a dog trainers page I read something that really rubbed me the wrong way.
I’ve been doing this everyday for long enough now to know I don’t believe in “beliefs” in dog training. I do not believe in force free. I do not believe in fear free. I do not believe in punitive training or dominance theory either. I don’t subscribe to anything other than helping dogs live the best life they possibly can and using the most current research and tools possible to help achieve that.
I subscribe to fear REDUCED, because unless I can actually ask a dog, I can’t say for sure they are fear FREE. That’s a godlike complex we humans are getting so attached to and it’s arrogant to assume we know exactly how an animal is feeling. I can’t possibly believe in force free, because I force my dogs to live in an environment that isn’t natural to them, wear leashes and collars and subscribe to my lifestyle. That’s a form of force no matter how you want to paint it. I believe in management. I believe in humor and in genetics and science. I do not believe in forcing a belief or a borderline religious affirmation into my work with an animal, or human for that matter, that I am working with. The second I do that, I’m limited in how I can help them.
I struggle so much in this industry watching some of the main “leaders” who preach and talk beliefs about training dogs yet aren’t actually in the trenches with them every day. Do they see what I am seeing? Are they doing this, day in, day out, and watching what’s happening? People have changed, dogs are changing, everything is so different. Flexibility is absolutely paramount at this point. What I see now in my office every day and in the slhelters is so different than even 6-7 years ago. Aggression, reactivity, serious behavior problems, they are all increasing. And NOT because of training techniques - the majority of the cases I see haven’t even started training yet. Puppies at 10 weeks old lunging and displaying mature aggressive behavior isn’t a product of any training technique.
The more beliefs we force on people the more the divide widens. I absolutely have my opinions on things, as you can see from this post, but I am also still willing to interact, discuss and talk to people who may see things differently. I don’t close them out because they don’t subscribe.
Positive reinforcement training isn’t ruining dogs. Neither is punitive training. What’s ruining dogs is the publics rapidly growing list of expectations we are putting on them (social media is a lot to do with this) while simultaneously reducing gene pools, pushing adoption without education on temperament evaluations and “it’s all how they are raised”, continuing to breed certain dogs without truly understanding their ethology or genetics, and the finger pointing in the industry rather than being willing to step out of our comfort zone and truly grow professionally as a group to meet the changes we are now seeing.
End rant. Back to training, rescuing and petting dogs.